Signed for Swinton along with Isherwood from Rochdale.



What do Leigh fans think of these two ex-players?

Thought Isherwoods back was goosed??? Was a very good second rower at this level when at Leigh - no idea about now.



Don't think Reay got a proper opportunity at Leigh - but a lot of people commented on his weak defence. Seemed ok to me though. Good strong runner @

Isherwood was good Reay wasn't!

Don't think Reay ever got a fair run in the side. Swinton look to be building a very handy side.

He couldn't tackle he had chances but did nowt very diassapointing.

One or two others also had chances, did nowt but still got regular games !

Stewart / Maden for starters. Thought Reay & Rudd were our best centres.

sorry pal no wonder we were relegated

Ahead of Nanyn?

thought Isherwood was very good indeed before his injury and weve had a lot worse than Sam Reay

Rudd???? He seems to be a favourite yet has done nothing to prove this yet imo. Very Dissapointing!

agree about Rudd dont see why people rave about him. Reay didnt do too much either Maden and Nanyn were better. Maden comes in for a lot of undeserved critiscm imo

i think your right about maden he took a lot of pressure off the forwards in the first half of the season although his form dipped later on after he signed his cntract

sam reay couldnt tackle a good dinner

andy isherwood was a good player for us in 2003 if he can recapture any where near that form you have signed a good un.

Reay looked in good shape when he had the ball in hand. Could beat a man. But his positioning in defence let him down. A good coach should be able sort that out. Wish Isherwood all the best good bloke as well as a good player.

Reay is poor. Isherwood was very good prior to bad injury. Have not seen him play recently.

Reay was awful, good luck to Isherwood

Sam was disapointing and Ishy has been too long away from us for us to judge fairly.

hIS SINGINGS GOOD THOUGH