Agree with this, although a few have included Hall (who was great in the 4N) Im not so sure myself that he is one of the best top 5 we have.

Quote ="Mr.Side"Out of curiosity, were would you put Sam in your rankings? But then again, youve just shown yourself as clueless again icon_smile.gif" alt="icon_smile.gif" title="Smile" />'" 6th.

Quote ="Mr.Side"Out of curiosity, were would you put Sam in your rankings? But then again, youve just shown yourself as clueless again icon_smile.gif" alt="icon_smile.gif" title="Smile" />'" 6th.

Can not see how you rate Roby at International level , everytime overlap on the left did he turn the ball back to the right .

Things like that make all the difference to a team.

If you think I am wrong suggest you watch games again .

Quote ="oud3pstander"Can not see how you rate Roby at International level , everytime overlap on the left did he turn the ball back to the right . Things like that make all the difference to a team. If you think I am wrong suggest you watch games again .'" Wasn't that Wilkin who kept coming inside instead of giving Yeaman the ball ? I don't think Wilkin gave him a single decent pass in the 3 games icon_mad.gif" alt="icon_mad.gif" title="Mad" />

Quote ="oud3pstander"Can not see how you rate Roby at International level , everytime overlap on the left did he turn the ball back to the right . Things like that make all the difference to a team. If you think I am wrong suggest you watch games again .'" Wasn't that Wilkin who kept coming inside instead of giving Yeaman the ball ? I don't think Wilkin gave him a single decent pass in the 3 games icon_mad.gif" alt="icon_mad.gif" title="Mad" />

Quote ="Offside Monkey"Someone once posted on here that if you do 100 things 1% better than you opponent, you'll win the game and, for me, that's the main difference between us and the aussies. They're just that little bit better than us at every little ">thing.'" icon_thumb.gif" alt="icon_thumb.gif" title="Thumbs up" /> We will never ever catch the Aussies up because quite simply rugby league is a much bigger game in Australia than it is in England so there is a much bigger pool of players to choose from and the domestic competition is of a higher standard - result, the best players available are of a higher technical quality than the best players available to England. Not dissimilar to comparing the English Premierleague with Scotland.

Quote ="Offside Monkey"Someone once posted on here that if you do 100 things 1% better than you opponent, you'll win the game and, for me, that's the main difference between us and the aussies. They're just that little bit better than us at every little ">thing.'" icon_thumb.gif" alt="icon_thumb.gif" title="Thumbs up" /> We will never ever catch the Aussies up because quite simply rugby league is a much bigger game in Australia than it is in England so there is a much bigger pool of players to choose from and the domestic competition is of a higher standard - result, the best players available are of a higher technical quality than the best players available to England. Not dissimilar to comparing the English Premierleague with Scotland.

Quote ="Odem"Tomkins Burgess Ellis Roby Graham Graham will soon move up the list when the NRL makes him an even better player. Burgess and Ellis are above Roby and Graham simply for that reason, they have proved they can succeed in the best league in the world to become top players doing it week in week out. Tomkins is top because he is Sam ">Tomkins.'" Agreed

Quote ="Odem"Tomkins Burgess Ellis Roby Graham Graham will soon move up the list when the NRL makes him an even better player. Burgess and Ellis are above Roby and Graham simply for that reason, they have proved they can succeed in the best league in the world to become top players doing it week in week out. Tomkins is top because he is Sam ">Tomkins.'" Agreed