I am happy sheen is keeping faith in Chris Atkins, think he could be a gem and the difference in us making top 8 or not, but what is disappointing is still no mean aggressive forward. Its ok just beating the teams your expected to be with in bottom 4. But when you go up against top 4 teams except Leeds, we will get mauled. Leeds were there for the taking but silly mistakes on there line and ours cost us.. lets hope junior vaivai gets his visa soon. Gets a few games at York and makes a impression in our team

I’d make an offer for Jason Clark if I was mr sheens sound like he wants to come and he knows he will not get another contact with souths he’s the type of player we need and can’t see souths say no tbh

He'd be a decent signing for any SL club, good age too.



Your back row is dreadful. You have Blair who can't tackle, Greenwood who makes about 4 meters per carry, and Clarkson who's not particularly good at anything.

I presume you have given your pearls of wisdom to TS as I don’t suppose he reads this forum

Blair is a decent SR makes good yards misses a couple of tackles in the matches you'd probably watched but he was covering for his centre imo him and Salter were very strong against Catalans

We also have Donaldson and Lawler to comeback in the SR also

Bair is a good player ,greenwood is good some games but needs to do more but is only young so will come in the end , Clarkson is a good squad player and is a grafter gets through the tuff stuff but not a starting player, we do need a big strong running second row in the starting 13 I’d say bobby bair would be a perfect lose forward don’t no why he never gets played there a strong runner with a good kicking game

Cracking young player is Lawler. He can go far in this sport.