Last weeks post Challenge Cup Final analysis by Jonathan Davies and yesterdays commentary by Eddie Hemmings had me annoyed, im not sure if anyone else was the same?



Davies's body language i.e. foot on the table, slumped in his chair said it all before he made reference to the two infamous decisions that went against Leeds. I dont think he could of been more gutted about the result, at one point Noble disagreed with him and was evidently picking up on Davies's attitude, then he preceeded to back Warrington for SL.



Yesterdays game was a fair result Warrington played well and deserved their win, however listening to Hemmings purring everytime something came off and his commentary was something to behold. I dont think he was impartial at all and was practically giddy at times. Im still trying to figure out if he is a Wire fan or a St Helens fan referring to them as 'The Saints' at every opportunity....



I know some of the commentary on the BBC and Sky have Wigan connections and its probably annyoing for other fans to listen to Phil Clarke or Brian Nobles comments but i would consider them fair, i wish i could have said the same for Davies and Hemmings.

Do we really have to go over this again?



It's getting like the Wire forum working itself into a frenzy every time Clarke comments on Wigan.

i can see where your coming from but hasnt this been covered in one of the other 5,000 threads on the same/similar subject?

As A Wigan fan I am sometimes embarressed by Phil's obvious bias. But he was a Wigan player and so was his dad and they hail from Wigan. So I can understand it. Maybe as a commentator he should be less obvious but he never takes pleasure in the plight of Wigan's oppposition and doesn't gloat when Wigan are obviously on top. And sometimes he supports Wigan's opposition in certain aspects of the game. Davies is obviously hacked off that on the occasions when he played for Widnes and Warrington he got stuffed by superior Wigan teams on practically every occasion that he opposed them - including Wembley. His attitude after the cup final bordered on unprofessional. And Eddy Hemmings can't make his mind up. He is a scouser right enough and does say some complementary things about Wigan when it is obvious that to do otherwise would be churlish. But doesn't he go for the jugular when he feels he is vindicated - like yesterday. And I don't suppose the Hull supporters appreciated the way he wrote them off yesterday either. As far as Eddy is concerned all the Wire have to do is turn up next Friday night...........well we have all done that and paid the price.