Noble is definitely under-achieving, no doubt about it. He has done every season at Wigan in terms of league position, but has been saved by a dramatic late surge in the Play Offs.



My main point, is that whilst he's not doing a great job, Shaun Edwards isn't a going to work a miracle and get you fighting for the title, not with these set of players. Shaun Edwards isn't even a proven coach, so I'd be aiming higher than to be honest.

When I read this I thought Ainscough had been left in France or something

I'd also say that a coach relies a little on the bloke whose job they've taken, in that they're stuck with their team for a while. It's hard to change the squad dynamic quickly in the salary cap era.



As usual we'll make a late surge, but i'd rather peak in September than in August like your lot

That wouldn't have been such a bad thing IMO.



As for Edwards, personally I think he was overrated.



Graham Lowe, on the other hand, is still coaching...

and why would that be a good thing?

Fill in the blanks you are MC ---------- = stains troll and i claim my five pounds .

I don't rate him. Yes he's scored a few tries, but anyone on the end of the balls/kicks he's had would have scored. Apart from a break down the wing at Leeds when he fended off Donald, which to be fair was impressive, I haven't seen him beat a man. Eddy keeps comparing him to Robinson which is just laughable really.

MC Hammer? Seriously, I know my opinion on Edwards won't match the consensus, but I reckon he was carried by Gregory. Different time and place and he would have looked ordinary.



As for Graham Lowe, yeah I know it ain't gonna happen, but the best coach we ever had, bar none.

Now who mentioned Edwards

BUSTED NOW GO AWAY .

I got called a troll, I assumed it was the Edwards comment, seeing as this thread is specifically about bringing him back to coach. Am I not allowed to post my opinions here? What do you mean, "busted"?

Knock your self out enjoy.