www.smh.com.au/rugby-league/leag ... 1bd9v.html Would be a good move for him if the deal gets done. The Knights are getting big money pumped into them thanks to fatty boy Tinkler.

www.smh.com.au/rugby-league/leag ... 1bd9v.html Would be a good move for him if the deal gets done. The Knights are getting big money pumped into them thanks to fatty boy Tinkler.

The Dogs would of been better off giving him the offer that there going too plus the money they've just used to re-sign Steve Turner. I think Turner is average at best and he only played Origin because he was aat the Storm and look what happened in that game. He missed some games through injury last year i think but when he played he was poor, especially in defence.

veryyy big loss for the doggies

I'm not sure... He wants to play centre but his defence isnt the best. I've always thought that he thinks he's better than he actually is.

i think the dogs are a good chance to keep him



reading todays papers they are using ennis to get him to stay and they can offload ryan to give him more money



$350,000 isnt a lot for a player of his potential and also hes very marketable

Yeah, jury's definitely still out for Idris. Kid can be devastating, but seems to rest on his talent too much.

yeah but when its josh dugan hes a super star eh?

Over rated at , mediocre at best. Good impact forward though, Dogs have Pritchard now, therefore Idris can go to knights

thanks for the bias champ



idris is hyped, duggan is hyped



apparently josh dugan is the best full back since clive churchill if you believe canberra fans





ive seen some games were duggans defence was like a turnstile

i never said that



i said 3 years ago they were similar type of players is all



idris is clearly a better player



and ive made my point



both duggan and idris are hyped, yet you back your guys

I think the term you're looking for is over-hyped. It was 2 years ago and you did say they were similar type players, to which I replied... Quote CGD="CGD"They're nothing like eachother except perhaps in vague looks.'" ...Which is still true. But you also said... Quote CGD="dallymessenger"laurie is a much better player than idris. laurie is the same kind of impact players as idris expect hes been doing the business for a bit whilst idris didnt do much last year if people are going to make a big deal about these types of players, id pick laurie as the better one'" ...My reply... Quote CGD="CGD"I think they've done just as well as eachother to be honest, and Laurie has only been playing NRL for like a month longer than Idris. But the main point is they're completely different players. Taking age into account, you'd have to say Idris looks to have the brighter future.'" ...And to come full circle, your reply... Quote CGD="dallymessenger"arent you a raiders fan?'" Exactly what you did in this thread, 2 years later. You haven't changed a bit. Link: viewtopic.php?f=2&t=399390

I think the term you're looking for is over-hyped. It was 2 years ago and you did say they were similar type players, to which I replied... Quote CGD="CGD"They're nothing like eachother except perhaps in vague looks.'" ...Which is still true. But you also said... Quote CGD="dallymessenger"laurie is a much better player than idris. laurie is the same kind of impact players as idris expect hes been doing the business for a bit whilst idris didnt do much last year if people are going to make a big deal about these types of players, id pick laurie as the better one'" ...My reply... Quote CGD="CGD"I think they've done just as well as eachother to be honest, and Laurie has only been playing NRL for like a month longer than Idris. But the main point is they're completely different players. Taking age into account, you'd have to say Idris looks to have the brighter future.'" ...And to come full circle, your reply... Quote CGD="dallymessenger"arent you a raiders fan?'" Exactly what you did in this thread, 2 years later. You haven't changed a bit. Link: viewtopic.php?f=2&t=399390

yes 2 years ago i thought laurie was a better player



today i dont fruit loop



still i should be happy you remember stuff i said 2 years ago



to sum you up : josh duggan walks on water



other teams young kids are over hyped

Just pointing out that my judgement is clearly better than yours, that's all.

Quote CGD="CGD" You haven't changed a bit. Link: viewtopic.php?f=2&t=399390'" Give him some credit. He does have another username too now Huddersfield1895 or whatever it is I can see the Bulldogs struggling this year. Losing Kimmorley and Hannant will be a big blow. And all this off field stuff regarding betting won't help either.

Quote CGD="CGD" You haven't changed a bit. Link: viewtopic.php?f=2&t=399390'" Give him some credit. He does have another username too now Huddersfield1895 or whatever it is I can see the Bulldogs struggling this year. Losing Kimmorley and Hannant will be a big blow. And all this off field stuff regarding betting won't help either.

your being biased bro, thats my point.



idris played on the bench for origin this year, hes no mug



duggan is a better player but both are being judged on potential now.



idris can be anything if he fixes up some of the problems in his game