Joined: Feb 21 2002 Posts: 31779 Location: The commentary box
Also posted on the international board, to which my reply was:
I don't think anyone is pretending everything is rosy. St Gaudens going into administration this week clearly highlights the issue in case anyone wasn't paying attention. I don't think there's a clear focus on what the LER is actually for, especially as it's the only professional league played during the European winter. This is something the FFRXIII could do with getting to grips with rather than dallying with the quinzistes of Stade Francais. I don't have a ready answer, but I'd love to at least kick-start a debate.
National recognition for the sport only comes when a club does something great - Toulouse to the Challenge Cup semis, Dragons to the final - when a page in L'Equipe is about as good as it gets. Having a club in Paris won't change that unless they do likewise. The excuses for not covering a Parisian team will be fewer, but they'll still exist. Moreover, having a team in Paris for the sake of having a team in Paris is a foolhardy, short-sighted idea - like a toddler giving it the 'look at me's. We've built houses on sand before and, who could have foreseen, they duly collapsed. Doing it again would only, again, financially imperil the FFRXIII and/or Super League. The Dragons and Toulouse are built on a solid foundation, as would be the proposed Aude club about which discussions are ongoing.
With clubs playing in the English leagues, aspiring players have something to aim for. An inability to tap into that is to the shame of the FFRXIII and club boards.
Simply put it is the most important decision in the last 40 years to bring in a 2nd french team come 2012. It is convincing the diehards at places like liegh, widnes, featherstone, fax and so on. Forget the pie in the sky usa pro thing, but given toulouse's trial form not much optimism for a top 2 finish. They need some talent input and fast. Let's hope the get the same favours as crusaders why uproot them from elite without some gurantee of a sl spot only richard lewis knows.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 51 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum