Batesy wrote:Yeah, you have and your right. Hes solid at FB, but to be competing we need every player in their best position, the same could be applied to tommy at 9. One thing about pat on the wing is he can out jump every opposition winger in the comp on his day, and this is something we miss IMO.
Your spot on re roberts, but I don't think we can force Pat and Roberts to compete, I think Pat's goal kicking alone will mean we might as well get shot of Roberts now. Its a real tough one, and you asked for what I think we should do. Well, I'm gona say I'm not Brian Noble, and I don't wish to be, so I'm gona leave it up to him hahaha
Nah Seriously, It has to be Pat at fullback. I can't justify dropping Roberts or Ainscough, and Phelps made that very very basic mistake, so I think I would use that as my excuse to not play him. However I'm not really sure I like that, because I like Phelps he's got a pair, and he runs hard and will always step up. We will also miss his hands as earlier stated.
Oh, and can I point out, how good does it feel to have this selection headache!!!! Rather than just say "well, we've got to play him becaue hes all we've got" we actually have the option of dropping players! wow! This is one headache I've missed
Your headache is slightly different to mine. I have the same concerns about selection but I feel differently.
Let me explain.
For me, (as explained) the FB position is a key position, and Pat isn't playing it well in attack. But I like Pat as a winger, but I also like Roberts (well think he has potential) and I think Ainscough is the best winger we have) So I've left in the situation where, for the good of the team, I want a true FB and either Richards/Roberts on one wing with Ainscough on the other. Playing Richards at FB till the option for a true FB becomes available.
Think..
Briscoe (for example)
Richards Gleeson Carmont Ainscough
Tomkins Orford/Dobson
Fielden Tommy Ross (for example)
Hock Lockers
Tomkins
------------------
Feka Prescott Riddell Roberts/Hansen
Wigan to play with (for example)
1st receiver Orford, with Joel to his left as loose, Sam to his right as the 2nd receiver, Briscoe deep lying 2nd receiver behind Sam.
Hock off Joel, with Carmont then Ainscough. Lockers next to Sam with Gleeson then Richards on the wing.
Fielden and Ross running tight dummy runner angles.
Tommy as 9 has the ball at dummy half, look at his options.
-Dummy run
-Feed directly to Joel as loose play down one side of the field.
-Play to Orford.
Orford options are:
Flat pass to one the props making it look like he's passing to Sam
-pass to sam
-pass behind sam to Briscoe
-Dummy and go.
-pass in the other direction to Joel.
-Kick for Pat
Each one of the options starts a fast motion attack.