MadDogg wrote:As I said in an earlier post, the only reason I think this might be a possibility is that Noble has a history of bringing back players to face their former clubs. To be fair to him in the majority of cases I think its worked but I certainly wouldn't be in favour of it this time.
I know what you mean, Mathers was "okay" there in the play offs last year, and some of Calderwoods handful of good performances came at Headingly. But when we have a great chance to finally build on some potential, I dont want an unnecessary risk to jepordise it, granted Mathers could come in and have a blinder and show what he can actually do, but I believe he simpily doesn't have the confidence to do it.
AJ wrote:I know what you mean, Mathers was "okay" there in the play offs last year, and some of Calderwoods handful of good performances came at Headingly. But when we have a great chance to finally build on some potential, I dont want an unnecessary risk to jepordise it, granted Mathers could come in and have a blinder and show what he can actually do, but I believe he simpily doesn't have the confidence to do it.
I agree. Thought Mathers was very poor in the playoffs last year though, I would refer to the regular season game at Headingley in which Mathers was Sky MOM.
I think the team will be the same again unless Ainscough misses out through injury. If he is injured then I would pick Pryce over Mathers with Pat to stay at fullback and Pryce on the wing. I saw Mathers play fullback for the reserves at the weekend and I agree with other reserve watchers that he didn't play well and stand out. Pryce on the other hand had a solid game in attack and was very strong defensively, especially in the 2nd half.
The only other change I would consider is swapping Prescott for Coley. Prescott has played very well in the last 2 reserve games and must be very close to a recall to the 1st team.Coley has played solidly in the last 2 games but is he any better than Prescott. Prescott will only get better as he plays more games in Super League.
Joined: Oct 10 2004 Posts: 2651 Location: the quiet west stand
Rogues Gallery wrote:Barring injuries, same as last week. They need to be rewarded for playing well, just as they should be dropped for playing poorly.
Just what I was going to post. We can't drop Coley. He played quite well and it would send out the wrong message, primarily to him but also to the rest. Injuries will happen and the form players in the reserves will get their chances.
Joined: Oct 10 2004 Posts: 2651 Location: the quiet west stand
Starting with Feka gives him a longer rest before his second spell.
If he does the first 20 minutes ( wow, yes, we're talking 20 minutes now), He can have approximately one hours rest before returning to do the last 20 minutes or 40 minutes before returning for the start of the second half.
If he comes on in the 20th minute, his rest time and options will be severely reduced.
Quote:Considering the nature of his injury, a hamstring tear, he has come back quicker than we anticipated and that is a boost for him and us," said coach Brian Noble.
"He has responded really well and we might get him back this week."
Quote:Considering the nature of his injury, a hamstring tear, he has come back quicker than we anticipated and that is a boost for him and us," said coach Brian Noble.
"He has responded really well and we might get him back this week."
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
