Your funny Jake

Not funny as you ,watts is head and shoulders above your tripe .

Watts is great player not that I was on about him at all I especially liked his performances for England in the World Cup

Nearly as good as the dobbins players that played for england

There's a lot of bilge being spewed from the darkside about our playing staff today............

Is pantomime season still going?



Come on then. Tell us who will play instead of Green, Bowden and Hadley. And bear in mind that if any of your answers are Abdul, Fash, Washbrook, Turgut or Matongo you have ruined your arguement anyway.

Possibly because he maybe means there can't be a 'Starting 17'?

He was the first one to use the term.

No I wasnt

Is this the right room for an argument?

No more youngsters or squad fillers,we have plenty of both.We got away with Ellis and Abdull in Championship as starting half's. Injury to Danny M and we are looking at Atkin and Marsh or a hodge podge of Blair/Quinlan. Another new half another large forward and a big centre/winger type is needed(as after Minns and Heff it's salter) Team spirit and emotion will get us through start of season .Where we find these players is another matter?

I do wonder what our "strengthening" aims are, last term we brought in Atkin early but he was really a target for this season.

So if we bring in a 2nd grade from Oz to play in front of him and Marsh what we're we buying ?

Also if we sign a Big powerful centre to replace Minns, what is the future for him and Salter ?

How many can we really expect York to take. We have to commit to some development, and without the luxury of an A team that as to be in the first 17.

If our targets are to allow squad rotation ala Tommy Lee, then it's forwards we need given our ageing front row and Bobby Blair.



If we are bringing in younger players who are happy to develop and wait for an opportunity then a centre/winger/fullback type would fit the bill, but wasn't that Butler-Fleming?

I think any new perminent signing may result in players been released.

Luke page to be announced at fridays friendly.

Cannot see we will strengthen if honest we will go with what we have.. cos other sites were signing Watson Helena and American world cup halve back. But I do wonder if we have a half coming in with McGuire saying if they get someone they will have to gel with team

Why would we want to replace Minns a proven SL player? Cover in case he or Heff is injured yes.

That is exactly my point Keith, are we looking for a starting centre, i.e. big powerful strong running NRL type or a player to cover Minns and Heff say someone like Salter.

I think we have to realise that there isn't going any new signings before we play Wakefield

Or maybe there will? Robert Lui would be a great signing and with Mar gone Reds are struggling again. If comes off would be just the quality signing we need. Fast unpredictable skillful tackles well without the stinky attitude.An upgrade on former imports

And it sounds like he wants to come what I have seen of Robert he would be good

lui would be a good signing and doom salford to bottom place

Don’t think lui is coming to rovers Salford have made a statement saying he is staying so who next ? Really do need to sign a good half back

Stateements mean nothing, if he wants to go it'll be all about the price.

Did Salford not come out with a statement Murdock masla is not for sale.. the only thing is when they say Kr have now moved on and signed another half back. Also des Lawson were did U here we have signed Luke page cos him and mose would strengthen us and sign lui we could be top 6

If the player wants to leave he'll leave regardless of what the club as they don't want a player there who doesn't want to play for the club they'll just hold out for the best price they can get