I honestly don't know your point.



I don't know when you think the ref could or should have stopped the game.

Lyne didn't have the ball to be able to play it, he lost it in a fair tackle, play on.



Beaumont was tackled, retained the ball but wasn't able to get up and play it, the game was stopped.



Two different situations, had McDonnell knocked the ball on, play would have stopped, as it was; there was no break in play.

Other way round we'd think it was great! Let's not let our sport go the same way as football. Fair play as far as I'm concerned!

The only point I'll make is that the KR player dropped the ball before the ref stopped play which is understandable since he had a broken leg but I'd assume under the letter of law it should be a knock on since the game hadn't been stopped at that point. Unless anyone knows different?

From losing the ball it took only 3 seconds from that moment for the ball to be touched down over the whitewash.

unfortunatly many just dont have the sense! personally ive seen him at fullback before,but many saw that 10 mins the other day were made no errors apart from lose the ball whilst unconcious but yet know better than the coaching staff who work with him day in day out? why are these people on here and not SL coaches?! the standard of hull fan has dropped a lot in recent times! Many not happy unless moaning,and they'll not think twice about destroying and tearing down our own players. Tommy lee didnt deserve all abuse he got,hall the same, a fair few others too ,sharp getting it now and reece about to get same treatment! tommy briscoe should count his lucky stars he's had the good fortune to have served his apprenticeship on the left outside yeamo and manu and not on the cursed right side cos these people would have probably found reason to tear him down too! also regards that England game not long ago i got to watch that game! tries from different areas and out the back flick passes and won a good few pens! along with MOM all amongst the best of acadamy players england has!

str



If the Hull players didn't react it was probably because they didn't see anything wrong with the tackle too. Strange that the ref didn't check he was ok though.

The fact Reece didn't drop a ball until he was knocked out

The fact he actually took a high ball knowing he was gonna be smashed within a split second of catching it

The fact he's still a young lad & is just starting out in that position

All point out that just maybe he has got the heart & skills to become a successful fullback if given a chance.

It was a brave catch followed by a well timed tackle, end of!

So perhaps people should hold back from slagging a young prospect off & actually encourage & support him.

Or maybe we should jump on any sign of weakness & shout abuse from the stands & post pages of nonsense on forums to totally ruin any young players confidence!

If Reece is going to try out at fullback he is gonna get caught out from time to time as I'm sure he'll do some good things. But let's not add to the pressure he'll be under like when Hall played there, or Tommy Lee played at halfback, or last year when Sharp was struggling.

How did you manage to time it,surely your hand would have been elsewhere on your body.

Lynne didn't do an awful lot wrong in that game other than take an almighty hit from a well timed kick. Maybe he should've jumped or turned his back but thats all part of the learning process in a new position. He was unfortunate that he took a big one and we scored from it.



The difference between the play on in this situation and the Beaumont was is simple. Beaumont was tackled, the tackle was completed and he was seriously injured. The ref stopped play at that point. Lynne wasn;t tackle complete, if Rovers hadn't scored I would assume the ref would have stopped play at the next tackle. As it was we we scored and there was a natural break and ultimately the half time hooter.



If you stop play for the Lynne incident then any player dropping the ball in a tackle would fake injury to stop the opposition playing on, we'd turn into football with players rolling all over and joggin off 5 seconds later.

Jesus....i agree with a Dobbin....sums it up to me

i think you can tell by the players reaction, and the fact not one ran in tells its own story,

Im all for giving young players a chance myself but he really needs loaned out to me as he just looks a weak link and I wouldnt have any confidence of having him as my fullback especially when we have good cover in Horne and whiting. Id even give Jack Briscoe ago as I just dont see any positives about this kid at the top level. He is one of the few kids im not excited about and Id like to see him prove himself somewhere else.

Note to Reece Lyne - Next time jump for the ball! The players running at you can't smash you in the head if you're in the air!



Easier said than done, I know! But that's the lesson I'd get from this. It's all well and good being brave (bravo for that as well!), but if you're going to get knocked out being brave, it's not exactly the smart option.

Before we scored obviously.

I mean the ref should stop playing advantages or letting play coninue until he has seen if every single player gets up from an impact.

Or perhaps he could let play continue and then asses it at the next stoppage/completed tackle....Oh wait he did.

Its over analysed.



Sissie Welham is a coward.



Every player on that pitch knows that the coward had 2 choices on how to hit an obviously open opposition player who could not defend himself.



1. Wipe him out with the intent to cause as much damage as possible or

2. Simply wait and see if the falling opponent tries to get up and continue (he had caught the ball)



THE GUYS A W4NKER...as proven by his continuous childish displays.



Wounder if he gets an injury so he can't play against us in the SL match.

No he isnt a W*nker - he is typical of every rugby league player, putting in a hit on a player that would lead to a dominant tackle and pressure on us coming away from our own line. He didnt intend to injure at all

Pathetic.

Give over, not one player on that pitch made a fuss about it.



You're as wet behind the ears as Reece is, he should have jumped for the ball. Why would Welham not tackle Reece at the earliest opportunity, instead, you suggest he lets him stand up, potentially avoid the tackle and run the length of the pitch through a jagged set of chasers.



Cheer up Mr Lyne, Welham will play in the next derby, Reece probably won't.

lets put into the correct context here

Our lad got creamed by a hit that would have had FC fans peeing in their pants had it been on dobson by yeaman or similar

no issue with the tackle, no issue with the hit itself, Lynne was wide open and there to get creamed , and creamed he was....

he isnt a full back as long as my sack dangles south and methinks he wont want to play FB again

hope the lad is ok now but hey its done its dusted he got wiped out and he will learn from it

"as long as my sack dangles south".

spot on judgement late hits after the ball has gone are imo cowardly acts of violence the tackle in question was close to perfect. i would have liked him to go across after the score to check on a fellow young pro ott game on

Agree 100% and the total lack of any involvement or calls from any FC player shows the lads know he simply got creamed and thats all there is to it....

I do recal most of the KR lads were looking over with concern from afar and well done to everyone in red and white for their applause as he finally got up and limped off,

Listen Lynne is young and inexperienced and got a read bellringer which wasnt a lack of technique on his part but was as precisely timed a tackle as you will see , no one wants a young fella hurt but the name of the game is to smash the opposition and he got smashed he sat up with his head at just the correct height to be taken off and was lucky it wasnt worse however i doubt there was time for lynne to have covered himself as he was hit the very second he caught the ball.

good tackle , the KR lad has nothing to feel bad about, he just played the game ...

lets move on now we got beaten and looking for excuses as lame as this hit is well embarassing....



one game in and we will clearly get better and the opener against wire will be totally different again ..

couldn't have jumped for it. only just got to it as it was and more or less took it waist height,hence been wide open to the hit! the high kicks were moving all over in the wind that end! prob why hall got his so wrong for greens try,it was in that same end!

don't understand this thinking! he's always played in a struggling team on a troublesome right side for us! and on few times he's played in games that should have been good for him ie wakefield at home last year the team pull out unbelievably bad performances! can't have been on a winning hull team more than a couple of times! none of the young uns could have shown up much better in my opinion based on seeing a lot of 20s last year home and away! jack was moved from full back at that level long ago never mind first team. a winger now. horne at least needs a chance to strike a proper half back combo with seymore,and whiting offers nothing more as a full back that a safe pair of hands! and even he prone to odd errors! would be agar style negativity putting whiting there,especially since even he sees himself as a 2nd row! since i've seen reece at 1 albeit at 20s level i find it ludicrous to write someone off for a ten min display were they did nothing wrong apart from lose a ball after been knocked out!