Did you not





at my suggestion that you had signed Thorman on 21/9/08 or did i misinterpret your post

Please tell me where you would have expected him to line up in the Shudds first 13?

in the halves with carney

seem to remember he turned us down before he joined Parramatta years back ?



good signing imo,now for a forward please

totally agree.

deffo need a forward does any one know if theres one in the pipeline ?

Highly unlikely, and you know it!

why who would play 6?

Carney, Robinson and Brown to fight it out in the halves.

i'd guess carney to start with either robinson or thorman and brown to cover from the centre.



i'd of thought we could of signed ayone from the 3 because huddersfield will want to balance their cap.

Keeping Webster and Dykes would provide adequate cover in the Halves.

Dykes/Webster at 7 . Thorman/ R.Horne at 6.

That would keep Berrigan at Hooker and Washbrook at Loose forward.

Robinson is an out-and-out 7. Brown is just awful wherever he plays.

no side can afford 4 well paid half backs when there short at centre and prop.

So does Horne.





You're joking. Aren't you?



Horne has a fantastic step off both feet which he uses pretty regularly.





Thorman may be somewhat more creative, but to call Horne "safe yet unspectacular" is frankly incredible.

Carney and Robinson are both Scrum halfs.



Brown is a centre and is not clever enough at SO. Most Hudds fans see Brown at centre or possibly becoming a no 13. I am surprised we have got rid off our only out and out stand off.

You either have a better player lined up or it is a silly mistake your club have made.



Hasn't Thorman struggled to hold down a place in the halves?

No Thorman was playing at Full back. when he went to SO everything got better. He was an automatic pick at 6







We are linked with THREE top players from down under and NONE of them are stand offs. If they all come off i can see us been in the top 3 next year and that is no exaggeration I can only assume that they are looking at playing Carney at 6 or possibly Brett Hodgson

Webster or Dykes to go then ? Or is Horne`s deal not as certain as suggested ?

webster due to the fact hes ooc and non fed.

Mentioned him earlier. Would be a excellent signing if we could get him.

Well thats my thoughts, cant see Hodgson playing 6, I actually think Brown could go well at 6 with Carney at 7.



So you guys could be going into next season without an established off-half, fair enough I suppose if your club dont see it as a problem.

prince would be my preference but after that orford or marshall because of their contract status.

Can't you and your Giants friend take your chat about his team somewhere else?

Orford wouldn't be my first choice either. Just with him been out of contrct end of next year.

The thing that annoys me was that his guy had chance to come to Hull, but didnt, and now he wants to because he hasnt lived up to all the hype he got when he went to Aus!



Why are we giving him another chance?



Good job its a 1Yr deal!