I disagree. I don't think his attack is a weakness, and I think it is entirely fair to compare him to those around him who are working with the same conditions. In particular I think it is massively flawed to assess his attacking game by measuring his tries scored and assisted against players in top sides that actually have functioning attacks whilst we have been woeful at that particular aspect of the game for most of his time here. If we had actually had any sort of semblance of a support game in the last 5 years his assists could easily be double what they are. Even then, assists don't always tell the full story.

The debate has been done to death and this thread doesn't need any more of it though, and we might see how he does in a better attack next season.

why are players worried about getting changed in front of carney? Does he have an unusually large willy and make them feel inadequate or something or does shaul look like nathan massey's ex?

The writing was on the wall with Westerman after his tirade to some fans after the first defeat at Cas .
He also sees himself as a first receiver type of player , as he alluded to in his rant .
A great bit of business by Hull FC . There is no need to panic with the cash generated . Wait for the right player .
Carney would have been a great signing without the allegations.
It was never likely to happen . Unity in a squad is paramount in my opinion. We saw that with the young Lads in the " Super 8's " . Those performances reignited my passion in the Club .
No let's get behind Hull FC and kick on .

You mean the same Pryce that has won everything in the game as a stand off.......Yeaman is the back up centre

carney is a good player, but imo as others have said unity is very important and its the right thing to look elseware

When he had legs why do you think Catalan signed him to play centre?