I agree. In which case, do you regard someone throwing a punch from behind a player with little chance of making contact with the ball and a strong possibility of hitting the man as "accidental"? I think that's stretching the definition somewhat! If I drove my car up onto the pavement intentionally, but didn't really want to hurt anyone, would that exonerate me of any wrong doing should I then run someone over or would you take the view that, if I didn't intend hurting anyone, I shouldn't have driven on the pavement in the first place and so am liable for any consequences?

Call me naive, but I don't think there have been too many cases in history where someone has 'accidentally' punched someone else in the face.



For all the histrionics among Raynor's supporters, in any normal walk of life he would pick up an immediate and rightful punishment, but this is the RFL of course, so we'll have to wait and see.

bravo

Danny McGuire *cough cough*.



How you all laughed and were glad he got injured, now rat boy gets knocked out and your pitch forks are out for anyone who dare have the audacity to laugh. Well im still laughing. Hope hes out for a long time

You still here? Whats up is your vibrator broken?

A small minority of stupid Wigan fans laughed not all of us. Your obiously in the stupid little minority of you clubs support too then.



Hoping Sam is out for a long time is pure desperation on your part

You are a very very sad individual........... If McGuire was laughed at it was because he got injured trying to cheat, Sam was a victim of an assault, two totally different events. If Raynor had broken his arm in the act, i would have laughed at the irony of his situation too

Oh dear!!! What's up? Does your peer group find you unattractive? Don't worry! the spots will clear up in time but you may need to work on your personality if you want to lose your virginity.

Katie Smithson = PHIPPS = Barry Mackenzie = Glorious League Freak.

Think you'll find Katie = Fleetwood Marc.

=banned

Beat me to it mofo!!

It was the greatest thing iv ever seen in my life.

No saddo. This was real life not some virtual computer game.

Turn around and go back along your slug trail.

Some horrible stuff in this thread





Horrible from Raynor, no defence and even though I don't much like Tomkins (admittedly one of the best players in SL) it was quite hard to watch.

In the same branch, Another point the fact that some wigan fans defending comments made when mcguire got injured is wrong also IMO. Whether he was cheating or not surely you wouldn't want to wish an injury on a player whoever it be.

You can't beat a soft get who keeps trying to come back under different names, and kees on getting caught.

0% League 0% union 100% Ar$ehole

The outrage is quite amusing when considered in the context of the reaction to Newton's unequivocally deliberate assault of Sean Long, which cause much more severe injury and was celebrated by a LOT of people on this board.



C'est la vie.

Therfore better than seeing your team win two Challenge Cups at Wembley = sad.

Every team seems to have some 'basic' supporters.

Then what a sad little existence you live

This!

If you comment is directed at me, i was not defending people. But many people did think it was ironic, and irony is amusing, not the injury. And for your info, i did post recently on the Leeds board to say how pleased i was to see Peacock and McGuire back and playing. But again, the two incidents are completely different, and i for one did not condone the injuries to Long.

Were you saying the same about Sam when he did Brett Morris in the WCC? Now that was a cowardly shot.