karetaker:Alffi_7:
I haven't seen Irwin play - but he's thought of very highly at the club. My concern would be throwing him in at 17 against a team like Saints who will play with lots of intensity.
Nothing against you personally but this kind of post really annoys me. I see this kind of post a lot oh we can?t play x,y or z against this or that team. Why not, it?s the best way to learn imo. We will learn nothing from him playing against Salford reserves etc. He as been selected for the Lancashire Academy Squad so is clearly highly thought of. He was in last week?s 21 and agin in this one, I hope it?s not just for experience around the first team learning how to order coffee.
I?m absolutely for young players getting opportunities, you?ll see I?ve been critical in the past about signing players like Greg Minikin as they block player pathways in my view. All I?m doing is raising a point that the coaching team may take the view he isn?t physically developed enough yet - I?ve heard plenty of coaches talk about this previously - Tony Smith, Gary Chambers etc. Just because one 17 year old (Lindop) is ready doesn?t mean every 17 year old is physically ready for a SL game. As I say, no idea if this applies to Irwin or not - just wondering really.