anyone who makes that many mistakes should not be used in an argument in favour of a player being better; in fact, it should really be the reverse.

Plus I'm sure McBanana has an obsession with Leeds players.

Does that mean Hardaker, Welham etc re playing better than Atkins?

Not a particulary strong argument.

I believe Atkins exclusion is nothing to do with his performances on the pitch.

Charnley is an electric talent. A tad suspect defensively but one hell of a player in a decent team. I'd guess he'd be similar to Jodie Broughton if he was at a lesser club.

I quite like Lee Briers hairstyle these days, very Sean Long like, windswept and interesting.