Don’t rate Smith myself for a scrum half he doesn’t create enough and his kicking game is awful. He has improved since his first season with us, but I wouldn’t go offering him anymore than what he’s on now as I honestly don’t think there would be any difference if Sneyd took his place he certainly wouldn’t create any less than Smith and he has a better kicking game something we desperately lack. Im not saying Sneyd will do a good job but I’d like to see him given a chance. Like others have said I’d rather it be spent in the forwards. Smith couldn’t break into Celtic Crusaders squad that tells a story in its self.



Don’t get me wrong I like Matty & love his enthusiasm and determination but that doesn’t justify a new bigger deal, I could play for Salford and have enthusiasm and determination but It wouldn’t make me good enough.



Obviously playing behind a beaten pack doesn’t help and as stated he is to inconsistent, wouldn’t mind him as a squad player but that’s not a luxury Salford can afford im afraid. Money better spent elsewhere.

Agree with the ball in hand Gleeson looks a threat, i just hope he works on his Defence which is pretty shaky.

Happy to keep Smith but not at any price, we have Sneyd who can step up, and with out limited budget there are other areas of the team that could do with strengthening.

Quote Diavolo Rosso="Diavolo Rosso"Wellens? icon_lol.gif" alt="icon_lol.gif" title="Laughing" /> Would like to see us keep Gleeson. Very under-rated centre in my opinion. Great game ">yesterday.'" Obviously missed the first 15 minutes when they walked through him and George bombed another try. Has an okay off-load and decent footwork but is a turnstile in defense. If we could get Goulding back from Wigan, I'd take, Jodie, Moon, Goulding, Williams as our centre wing partnerships. Forgot to add, anyone who didn't attend and watched in on Sky, why was they checking the Gleeson try for what seemed like 5 minutes.

Quote Diavolo Rosso="Diavolo Rosso"Wellens? icon_lol.gif" alt="icon_lol.gif" title="Laughing" /> Would like to see us keep Gleeson. Very under-rated centre in my opinion. Great game ">yesterday.'" Obviously missed the first 15 minutes when they walked through him and George bombed another try. Has an okay off-load and decent footwork but is a turnstile in defense. If we could get Goulding back from Wigan, I'd take, Jodie, Moon, Goulding, Williams as our centre wing partnerships. Forgot to add, anyone who didn't attend and watched in on Sky, why was they checking the Gleeson try for what seemed like 5 minutes.

Quote programmethrower="programmethrower"Forgot to add, anyone who didn't attend and watched in on Sky, why was they checking the Gleeson try for what seemed like 5 ">minutes.'" Obstruction - there was a runner (Nero I think) who ran in front of Patten before he passed to Gleeson. Agree with the comments about Gleeson - whilst he shows a bit of flare in attack, his defense is woeful. Wouldn't be too fussed if he left. In fact, I could say that about most of the members of the squad with the exception of Broughton, Moon and maybe Holdsworth.

Quote programmethrower="programmethrower"Forgot to add, anyone who didn't attend and watched in on Sky, why was they checking the Gleeson try for what seemed like 5 ">minutes.'" Obstruction - there was a runner (Nero I think) who ran in front of Patten before he passed to Gleeson. Agree with the comments about Gleeson - whilst he shows a bit of flare in attack, his defense is woeful. Wouldn't be too fussed if he left. In fact, I could say that about most of the members of the squad with the exception of Broughton, Moon and maybe Holdsworth.

In fairness to Smith after I slated him vs Bradford, thought he had a good game yesterday. As others have said about Gleeson, he is great in attack but woeful in defence.

Quote programmethrower="programmethrower" Forgot to add, anyone who didn't attend and watched in on Sky, why was they checking the Gleeson try for what seemed like 5 ">minutes.'" The obstruction was cleared after 30 seconds they then went to the grounding and used every camera angle in the stadium to try and disallow it, Sky even got pictures from the space station icon_mad.gif" alt="icon_mad.gif" title="Mad" />

Quote programmethrower="programmethrower" Forgot to add, anyone who didn't attend and watched in on Sky, why was they checking the Gleeson try for what seemed like 5 ">minutes.'" The obstruction was cleared after 30 seconds they then went to the grounding and used every camera angle in the stadium to try and disallow it, Sky even got pictures from the space station icon_mad.gif" alt="icon_mad.gif" title="Mad" />