Quote ="jarvis12345"On what basis are Smith, Ablett and the completley untested Keinhorst better options than Atkins, I dont think im the only one who thinks he is the best LC in the league.
Hardaker BJB Watkins Atkins Hall would be an awesome back 5. I agree chisholm should be tried but I would rather sign Atkins if he was available.'"
My comment is around the fact we would have to pay more for Atkins in wages then we would be paying Smith, Ablett and Klienhorst put together. Hence by far the better options. Ablett is a better all round player than Atkins, Smith can play anywhere in the 1 to 7 positions and Kleinhorst from what I have seen has some potential.
You also missed my other 2 comparisons in Watkins and Hardaker who for me are better than Atkins long term.
