haha

Of course it needs investigating but surely it's the official on te side who's job that is? I'm a Salford fan and was at the game, there is a official who's only job as far as I see every week is to count the replacements & let them on & off. If he was doing his job right it wouldn't have happened. If we end up losing te points in will be outrageous, it wouldn't have affected the game as muc as you lot having 12 men so we were due an extra man anyway!!

Its just plain wrong and its unfair but nowt will happen other than a piddly fine and a slapped wrist.

As bad as halibut is, how is this his fault? He may count them on the commencement of both halves but after that he's a little too busy to be constantly counting.

I agree it the fourth official and Salford at fault

Its not necessarily the 4th officials fault, every game an interchange official turns up as well, nothing to do with rfl, he is just a local ref who goes that week, normally he does the subs of the home team, the 4th official normally does the away team, and the 4th official writes down who comes on and off, but if he cant see who goes on or off the interchange official is supposed to go up to him and say 10 off 8 on etc, it is then logged for future reference.



He has a folder and the dugout has the cards with numbers on, the player is given the numbered card to give to the io/4th official when he goes onto field, but he is not allowed to do the sub until the player coming off is either within 10m and advancing to touchline or gone off from a try etc behind the sticks or taken off over the far touchline by the doc/physio.



The i/o is meant to stand there quietly watching and getting ready for subs and not allowed to clap etc when a try is scored, but sometimes you cant help it..i know of one who screamed abuse at ganson when he did it at bradford and was shouted at by the m c.

any news on this?

£10k fine, shambles

That's a big fine considering saints only got a couple of hundred for the same thing?

£5000 pounds a point, the RFL should give you the money seeing as you were the ones robbed.

£10'000 fine. and one of koukashs horses won the big race at Chester today. £70,000 prize money , life isn't fair Eh!!

















`

Yep. Salford should have forfeited the points for that kind of cheatery, end of.

£ 10k fine won't put a dint in the wallet of Ming the Merciless will it?

Nope....

basically this says that rich owners can have all 17 on the pitch and its fine..... in a close game, that could very well decide who takes the wooden spoon they cheated. they benefited from cheating by winning the game, as there is no way that having an extra player on the pitch and it not. RFL bottled in from the rich owner.



sorry cas, robbed twice!

we should've done it in the "million pound game"



play 14 players all match, take a tenK fine, relegate wakefield!



...somehow I think the punishment for us would've involved a points deduction.



Can't irritate Saddam, Abu, Alan though can we, or whatever his name is.

I think the fine is incredibly harsh considering Cas were not guaranteed to score in that time.

I never expected to receive the 2 points from this outcome, but I feel that the RFL have now set a president, based upon the rumoured league restructuring, I await the time when a team fighting against relegation does the same thing, and ends up staying up in the top flight. A £10K fine will be nothing in comparison to the money lost/gained!

The fine won't affect Dr Koukash one iota, but imagine (without bias against either of our two clubs) if our clubs were hit with a £10,000 fine, it would cripple us! It was I'd assume a mistake, mistakes do happen, I just think it's an incredible amount of money, that's if the RFL believe it was a mistake!

Giving points to Cas was not an option open to the RFL according to their own rules. They could have indirectly benefited by a points deduction to Salford effectively voiding the game.



Instead the RFL top up the bank account. If I was a cynic, I would be keeping my eyes open for new facilities being built at Bradford costing in the region of £10,000.

^ never thought of that, that's not a bad shout

Tony Smith of Warrington veiws here :- www1.skysports.com/rugby-league/ ... 6/8709853/

Tony Smith of Warrington veiws here :- www1.skysports.com/rugby-league/ ... 6/8709853/

DAVE@CAS1990 wrote: "Can't irritate Saddam, Abu, Alan though can we, or whatever his name is."



I see good old fashioned 'tolerance' is still thriving in West Yorkshire

. Give me strength...

I don't think "tolerance" has anything to do with this. Dave is just calling a spade a spade IMO.

I don't know his first name - hence it was a little bit of sillyness that crept in. I apologise for how tight your bum is on that one.



I can tolerate him, until he opens his trap. That's the same with any ignorant rich man - regardless of their first name





Hope this clears up any confusion - I have my own opinions of "that" nature but know when and when not to air them.



My point still stands, the RFL are terrified the'll put him off