Joined: Feb 27 2002 Posts: 18070 Location: On the road
LadyDee
I think you underestimate the physcological effect - we also don't know how seriously Saints took the game - if they took it seriously and got beat easy then they will be nervous of what could happen on Sat.
If they genuinely believed they could beat anyone if they really put there mind to it - then defeat in the last two weeks will have seriously dented there confidence.
I think if we play as we did on Saturday we should win
Joined: May 08 2002 Posts: 277 Location: Tingley,Leeds
mathers in for cummins, you can tell the guy's itching to get on....just look at saturdays game, the amount of times he was told to get off the pitch!haha......
Joined: Feb 20 2002 Posts: 1719 Location: Leeds - Gildersome
Connolly (Picks himself, had a solid performance on Sat).
Calderwood (Having a good season, deserves place).
McKenna (Good game on Sat, should be back to full potential for semi).
Senior (Cannot leave him out of the side, just wish he would help his winger in defence).
Cummins (His form may be erratic, however cannot leave someone with his experience out of the side, did little wrong on Sat, needs more support in defence).
Dunemann (Defensively he is rock solid, really closed down Scully and Long on Sat, much the same needed for the semi).
Maguire (Can create much more than Burrow in attack, deserves a start).
McDermott (Need a solid start in the forwards, you don't get more solid than Barrie).
Disko (Having a good season, no reason for him not to start).
Ward (Works well with Barrie, wouldn't risk Bailey).
Furner (Showed how much we missed him against Huddersfield).
Adamson (Great in defence, makes good yards in attack).
Sinny (He has come on leaps and bounds since being given the captaincy).
Subs
Macdonald and Feather (Both great coming off the bench, real impact players).
Poching (Made alot of difference when he came on for Adamson on Sat, deserves to keep his place).
Burrow (Much better off the bench when Saints forwards are tiring).
I have not included Chev or Bailey, as they are both coming back from injury, and should not be risked.
I have not included Mathers, because although he is a great prospect for the future, he does not have the experience in big cup games.
Robo's phrase of the day "Yorkshire Born and Yorkshire Bred, strong in the arm and weak in the head."
Joined: Jun 19 2002 Posts: 14970 Location: Campaigning for a deep attacking line
Roborhino wrote:Connolly (Picks himself, had a solid performance on Sat).
Calderwood (Having a good season, deserves place). McKenna (Good game on Sat, should be back to full potential for semi).
Senior (Cannot leave him out of the side, just wish he would help his winger in defence). Cummins (His form may be erratic, however cannot leave someone with his experience out of the side, did little wrong on Sat, needs more support in defence).
Dunemann (Defensively he is rock solid, really closed down Scully and Long on Sat, much the same needed for the semi). Maguire (Can create much more than Burrow in attack, deserves a start).
McDermott (Need a solid start in the forwards, you don't get more solid than Barrie). Disko (Having a good season, no reason for him not to start). Ward (Works well with Barrie, wouldn't risk Bailey).
Furner (Showed how much we missed him against Huddersfield). Adamson (Great in defence, makes good yards in attack). Sinny (He has come on leaps and bounds since being given the captaincy).
Subs
Macdonald and Feather (Both great coming off the bench, real impact players). Poching (Made alot of difference when he came on for Adamson on Sat, deserves to keep his place). Burrow (Much better off the bench when Saints forwards are tiring).
I have not included Chev or Bailey, as they are both coming back from injury, and should not be risked.
I have not included Mathers, because although he is a great prospect for the future, he does not have the experience in big cup games.
Agree entirely! Except switch Dunemann and McGuire so that McGuire's at stand-off and Dunemann's at scrum-half. Gives Mcguire more space and Dunemann's still good at scrum-half.
If Saints are going to win on Saturday, my bet is that it will be on the back of a great performance from either Sculthorpe or Long. I saw nothing in Dunnemann's performance the other day to suggest that he should play anywhere but at stand off against Sculthorpe in the semi.
I really like McGuire as a player, but asking him to contain the best player in Britain in a game like this after only 4 or 5 league starts is a bit much.
If that sounds negative, the way I'm looking at it is that if we MATCH them in the halves, we'll probably win because IMO we can beat them in the forwards and at least match them in the threequarters. With that in mind, I'd stick with what worked so well the other day.
The way Wayne worked off the bench on Saturday was fantastic.
Bailey or Ward is tough, on the one hand Wardy is steady and won't let us down. But Bailey would cause more trouble or Saints.
I don't expect Saints to play as badly in the semi, but I still feel we can beat them again.
Not sure what type of injury it was that Bailey had (ribs ?), but unless he was 100% fit I wouldn't risk him. If he were to break down in the first ten, that's a big part of our game and a big advantage to us out of the window.
As long as everyone is fit I'd go with Davids team. McGuire at scrum half ahead of Burrow would be interesting to see. Other than his scurrying runs its hard to see what Burrow has over Danny, the moment when Danny set-up the no try was a fantastic bit of natural talent, skill and vision, Burrows kicking seems to consist of a run of the mill grubber. Dunnemann has to play at stand-off against Sculthorpe.
Bailey should be in ahead of Ward.
I think you underestimate the physcological effect - we also don't know how seriously Saints took the game - if they took it seriously and got beat easy then they will be nervous of what could happen on Sat.
If they genuinely believed they could beat anyone if they really put there mind to it - then defeat in the last two weeks will have seriously dented there confidence.
I think if we play as we did on Saturday we should win
I have to disagree slightly. Yes, the fact that we beat them does give a psychological advantage if harnessed in the right way. The thing they have to be cautious about is not to get in the mindset that we've beaten them once so we'll easily do it again as has been seen in the past. If ever a coach can psych his team up for a game it is Millward which is why in my opinion it is better for them to put last weeks game to one side and prepare themselves mentally and physically for this weeks match. Last week was a massive effort, but this week will need a bigger push. If Big Wayne wants to reenact his try this week though, i won't be complaining!!
Some people are born crying, live complaining and die disappointed.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
