Joined: Feb 11 2011 Posts: 2125 Location: Wakefield
Trojan Horse wrote:He’s only till end of 2025. Signed for 2923/2024 at Cronulla do next season is his last. Perhaps afterwards the lure of playing with his brother might open up an opportunity.
Most likely as you say unless we use the marquee spot with some serious coin pumped in it won’t happen.
I wonder who this prop is or even if it’s a prop at all. I’d have thought we’d be looking at a second rower or 9 if anything.
It would be an amazing signing Braden, he’s a top line front rower. Not sure who the NRL prop is, I got wound up the other day we were signing Kurt Capewell!! There will be a lot of names flying about, especially with teams like Parramatta, South Sydney etc getting new coaches and refreshing their rosters. I know it’s a long shot but I believe big Reegan Campbell-Gillard is being shopped about, imagine that!!
Joined: Feb 11 2011 Posts: 2125 Location: Wakefield
alegend wrote:So you are saying the recruitment manager is the guy in charge and Powell as nothing to do with the recruitment .And most fans are saying that bringing in a player that as played 26 times in two seasons because of injuries is the best we can do for one of the key position on the park. Think fans are getting carried away with us winning so many matches this season. In most matches this season our 6,7and9 have been out played and that was before the injury Well smell the coffee we will not get away with it next year Next year we will find out if Mr Powell is a good coach or was he lucky to have Finn ,Gale ,and Mcshane all in there prime at Cas
Trojan Horse wrote:He’s only till end of 2025. Signed for 2923/2024 at Cronulla do next season is his last. Perhaps afterwards the lure of playing with his brother might open up an opportunity.
Most likely as you say unless we use the marquee spot with some serious coin pumped in it won’t happen.
I wonder who this prop is or even if it’s a prop at all. I’d have thought we’d be looking at a second rower or 9 if anything.
Assuming they're off contract, I'd guess it'd be one of Peter Hola (Raiders), Liam Knight (Bulldogs), Makahesi Mankato (Eels) or Martin Taupau (Broncos). Outside chance of Jordan McLean or Matt Lodge. I'd like it to be Knight.
I'd also prefer an out-and-out line-running second rower. Not loads of top class ones about, but I really like Jack Williams at the Sharks. Absolute workhorse but can also run good lines.
Butcher wrote:Assuming they're off contract, I'd guess it'd be one of Peter Hola (Raiders), Liam Knight (Bulldogs), Makahesi Mankato (Eels) or Martin Taupau (Broncos). Outside chance of Jordan McLean or Matt Lodge. I'd like it to be Knight.
I'd also prefer an out-and-out line-running second rower. Not loads of top class ones about, but I really like Jack Williams at the Sharks. Absolute workhorse but can also run good lines.
Certainly seems to be plenty of forwards available if that list is to go by.
Martin Tapau has been banded about last 2 seasons and it seems his agent just shops him to get him another NRL deal every season. Didn’t we offer him a deal for 2023? I’m not sure I’d be keen on that.
Can’t say that I’m not excited to find out who we have signed as I reckon there’s a big one still to come.
Joined: Oct 04 2008 Posts: 20994 Location: wakefield
Trojan Horse wrote:Certainly seems to be plenty of forwards available if that list is to go by.
Martin Tapau has been banded about last 2 seasons and it seems his agent just shops him to get him another NRL deal every season. Didn’t we offer him a deal for 2023? I’m not sure I’d be keen on that.
Can’t say that I’m not excited to find out who we have signed as I reckon there’s a big one still to come.
We don't need to go for old past their best players. I'd rather we shopped in the Rodwell and Uele market.
A dog is not considered a good dog because he is a good barker. A man is not considered a good man because he is a good talker - Buddha
Joined: Oct 13 2004 Posts: 36097 Location: Poodle Power!
alegend wrote:So you are saying the recruitment manager is the guy in charge and Powell as nothing to do with the recruitment .And most fans are saying that bringing in a player that as played 26 times in two seasons because of injuries is the best we can do for one of the key position on the park. Think fans are getting carried away with us winning so many matches this season. In most matches this season our 6,7and9 have been out played and that was before the injury Well smell the coffee we will not get away with it next year Next year we will find out if Mr Powell is a good coach or was he lucky to have Finn ,Gale ,and Mcshane all in there prime at Cas
Give it a rest. I also want to make one thing clear, you don’t speak for most fans, just a tiny minority.
Players get injured, sometimes they have a run of them and then they come back strong. Happened to Ashurst for a start. Would you like me to give you a list?
Truman has played 130 first team games and he’s only 25, to any reasonable person that’s a good return. If he gets past his injury blip then he could easily finish on 300 games when he retires, if that’s injury prone then I give up.
And before you say ‘if’, that ‘if’ applies to every player in the world, they are all only one game away from a career ending injury.
Joined: Oct 04 2008 Posts: 20994 Location: wakefield
To add to that, he's played more games per season for Hull than TJ did for us in his last three seasons.....but Catalan bought him anyway and he gave them a very good return. The 'injury prone' thing is a myth. There are lots of players who have big injuries and make a full recovery.
A dog is not considered a good dog because he is a good barker. A man is not considered a good man because he is a good talker - Buddha
FIL wrote:I'm told that Matty Russell is a done deal, along with the NRL prop I mentioned last week (still don't know who though) and we are waiting on quota clarification so that we can then hopefully sign Parcell
Hear similar about an NRL player, but 2nd row not prop, wouldn't give a name either, also Rouke a done deal and hasn't broke the bank, but not heard anything on M Russell, been quite accurate in the past.
Joined: Oct 26 2006 Posts: 13785 Location: No bowl, stick, STICK!
PopTart wrote:To add to that, he's played more games per season for Hull than TJ did for us in his last three seasons.....but Catalan bought him anyway and he gave them a very good return. The 'injury prone' thing is a myth. There are lots of players who have big injuries and make a full recovery.
Jonny Lomax being the prime example. Blighted with serious knee injuries in his earlier career and written off by most, but since he got over them he's been one of the best and most consistent halves recently.
Anyway Al always likes a good moan, always banging on about pace but never citing who he would actually like us to bring in. Not even a wish list of unlikely targets, let alone who is available.
Joined: Oct 04 2008 Posts: 20994 Location: wakefield
Khlav Kalash wrote:Jonny Lomax being the prime example. Blighted with serious knee injuries in his earlier career and written off by most, but since he got over them he's been one of the best and most consistent halves recently.
Anyway Al always likes a good moan, always banging on about pace but never citing who he would actually like us to bring in. Not even a wish list of unlikely targets, let alone who is available.
Lomax is a great example....of a determined player and a club supporting their player too.
A dog is not considered a good dog because he is a good barker. A man is not considered a good man because he is a good talker - Buddha
Users browsing this forum: Spookisback and 54 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
