Big lads mate wrote:As a team probably the worst they have played, but only 10 points in it. The only positive to take away from it. Wayward passes in silly areas and too many unforced errors. No player goes out there to make errors, just wasn’t Warringtons day, got no complaints about the result. One thing that I did notice was the crossing that wasn’t pulled by Kendall. But hopefully more finals to come.
I don’t think that the wayward passes were the biggest problem the real issue is the Wigan pack was dominant which resulted in Wire trying to play round them. Defensively Wigan produced their A game, offensively I would say there is plenty of improvement. Wire have definitely taken a big step forward and they need to build on the foundations that Burgess has put down by integrating their juniors and recruiting better.
Joined: Jun 25 2006 Posts: 13739 Location: Forum21
Zig wrote:I don’t think that the wayward passes were the biggest problem the real issue is the Wigan pack was dominant which resulted in Wire trying to play round them. Defensively Wigan produced their A game, offensively I would say there is plenty of improvement. Wire have definitely taken a big step forward and they need to build on the foundations that Burgess has put down by integrating their juniors and recruiting better.
Our pack is not consistently good enough against the bigger packs. We were completely and utterly dominated in the middle on Saturday, it wasn't even a contest. I fear we are not recruiting for props any more as the vox populi seems to be "we have plenty". But Burgess is well placed to assess.
Wires71 wrote:Our pack is not consistently good enough against the bigger packs. We were completely and utterly dominated in the middle on Saturday, it wasn't even a contest. I fear we are not recruiting for props any more as the vox populi seems to be "we have plenty". But Burgess is well placed to assess.
Yep we need a new dominant big powerful front row, Cos Saturdays front row are only bench quality against the top teams
Joined: Oct 06 2005 Posts: 2679 Location: Warrington
I don’t think there’s need to fly into panic mode, the team had a stinker - it happens. Saints had an absolute mare in 2019 (very similar to our performance) they soon got over it. Friday is massive as it will tell us a lot about this side and any chances for the rest of the season.
Joined: Jun 25 2006 Posts: 13739 Location: Forum21
ratticusfinch wrote:I don’t think there’s need to fly into panic mode, the team had a stinker - it happens. Saints had an absolute mare in 2019 (very similar to our performance) they soon got over it. Friday is massive as it will tell us a lot about this side and any chances for the rest of the season.
Agreed no panic, just an observation of the pack. Let's hope we bounce back with a good win.
That was very disappointing and a year too soon. In our team there were: 4 CC Winners 2 WCC Winners 3 GF Winners 9 International players 1 State of Origin Winner 2 players with 10 NRL Seasons
Joined: Feb 13 2008 Posts: 433 Location: Egham-ish
My assessment as a Wigan fan. I brought two mates with me, one a big both codes rugby fan who doesn't follow a team, and one who is a football fan who had never been to a rugby game before. They both very much enjoyed the day. It's interesting to me that while, as rugby league fans, we are seemingly all worrying about the optics of empty seats and what we need to do to fill the stadium and get a better atmosphere, their attitude was very positive. They thought the crowd was really impressive and the sense of occasion was very much part of the day for them. My football fan mate was very pleased that he could have a pint in his seat, and was pleasantly surprised that we had Warrington fans sat right in front of us, with no worries over segregation.
To the match itself, I think Burgess was probably right to focus on the fact that 12 of the 17 had not played in finals before. Wigan only had two where that was the case and I really thought it showed. I had a good chat with one of the Warrington fans at half-time and we both agreed that the big game experience was making a difference. The interesting there to me is that I think it was the players with finals experience that suffered. I wonder if they felt too much pressure to stand up and be the leaders today, rather than just playing their usual games. Williams, Powell and King all had unusually poor games. Warrington's last tackle options were poorer than usual, both in choice and execution. But the biggest factor, as several have mentioned, was in the forwards. Wigan got on top early there and never let go. Thompson and Cooper looked every inch the England veterans that they are and Vaughan and Harrison, both of whom I rate highly, looked as poor as I have seen them this season. Philbin was missed. He has looked much more like the player of 2019 this year, and his aggression may have helped out there. French and Field had the Warrington defence rattled a lot of the time, hence why King shot out of the line when he shouldn't. They say you have to lose one to win one, and I wonder if this was your lose one. I still feel the Grand Final is going to be any two of Wigan, Warrington and Saints and it could easily go differently then. As for the officiating, I didn't have a problem with most of it, barring the obvious incredulity at the harsh yellow cards and the long deliberations over the French double movement. Ball carrying arm clearly hit the deck while the tackle was effected, and there was a clear second movement to lift the arm and ground the bball over the line. Not sure why it needed all that time, especially after being sent up as a no-try. Thanks to the Warrington fan sat in front of me for welcoming my mate to his first rugby match and sportingly offering us a handshake at full-time. Rugby league fans are truly the best,
"I have this system where I support England first, then the other Home Nations, then the rest of the Commonwealth, then the rest of the World, then France."
On the double movement; if I'm not mistaken you are allowed to move your arm if you are still moving, a point that seems to be being overlooked. Promoting the ball only comes into play when your momentum is stopped. French said he thought it was a try because he was still moving and there's an argument to say he's right. Not that it mattered in the end, of course.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 215 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum