Zig wrote:Mate, that’s what I call trying to defend the indefensible. Some of the posters on RV have no rugby league knowledge and little between the ears. There are however others, like yourself, who I like to debate with.

Field is all class as is Welsby and French end of story, no debate and no animosity. There are just not enough of them in SL.

With regard to the WCC my view is that the best team will win. If that is Penrith then I acknowledge their achievement. If we manage to take the spoils then I will be thrilled. Either way, I am looking forward to seeing some top NRL athletes and one of the greatest number 7s who has played the game. Watching Cleary is, in my view, worth the admission fee alone. By the way, don’t be surprised if Welsby is on Penrith’s radar for the 2025 season. Had Jack received an offer from, let’s say, a more high profile NRL club his bags would have been packed. Personally, I am glad that he stayed as SL can’t afford to lose players like him.

The Yellow Giraffe wrote:Where have I defended certain comments? I agree some of the stuff on there is ridiculous. What I’m saying is that it’s a small minority and I don’t understand why people on here talk as though everyone on Redvee shares the same views. Most people on there are civil and rational and debate things in the same way as they do on here. Yes there are a few people who take it too far and I’m in no way defending that; I’m saying don’t tar everyone with that brush.

Zig wrote:I’m not sure it’s a minority when it comes to Wigan.

The Yellow Giraffe wrote:Where have I defended certain comments? I agree some of the stuff on there is ridiculous. What I’m saying is that it’s a small minority and I don’t understand why people on here talk as though everyone on Redvee shares the same views. Most people on there are civil and rational and debate things in the same way as they do on here. Yes there are a few people who take it too far and I’m in no way defending that; I’m saying don’t tar everyone with that brush.

The Yellow Giraffe wrote:Where have I defended certain comments? I agree some of the stuff on there is ridiculous. What I’m saying is that it’s a small minority and I don’t understand why people on here talk as though everyone on Redvee shares the same views. Most people on there are civil and rational and debate things in the same way as they do on here. Yes there are a few people who take it too far and I’m in no way defending that; I’m saying don’t tar everyone with that brush.

Zig wrote:You said one person, which is not true. Therefore by default you are defending others that have made stupid and non-factual comments.

The Yellow Giraffe wrote:I'm really not.

Jason65 wrote:Yes you are

The Yellow Giraffe wrote:Wow it's like being in a playground.

At no point have I defended a particualr comment or set of comments. What I have said is that I acknowledge that there are some idiots on there and some stupid things said, however it's unfair to judge everyone on that and that it's not "everyone on redvee is saying bla bla bla" like some people on here claim.

If you can point out where I have actually defended or justified a specific comment then I will eat my own arm.

The Yellow Giraffe wrote:Wow it's like being in a playground.

At no point have I defended a particualr comment or set of comments. What I have said is that I acknowledge that there are some idiots on there and some stupid things said, however it's unfair to judge everyone on that and that it's not "everyone on redvee is saying bla bla bla" like some people on here claim.

If you can point out where I have actually defended or justified a specific comment then I will eat my own arm.