Post subject: Re: Salford placed in special measures
Posted: Fri Nov 24, 2023 3:56 pm
vastman
International Chairman
Joined: Oct 13 2004 Posts: 36099 Location: Poodle Power!
The Avenger wrote:Toulouse scored higher than us on IMGs ratings so they would probably get the gig ahead of us anyway
I get your point but I'm not sure about that. If Salford fail to start this season, and the IMG system doesn't start until 2025, then past protocol is that the demoted team regains it's place by default.
Also think it's fair to say that we may well soon overhaul Toulouse in the ratings, as those I believe were provisional. The Toulouse buy ou,t last I heard, had not yet gone through.
Just thinking out loud, but after a frenzied start, the signings have died down completely - maybe we are holding fire, just in case. I suspect someone like Ellis will know the situation Salford are really in better than most, seems to do his research.
However it needs sorting, because whoever replaces Salford should the worst occur, are quickly running out of time.
Certainly not the simple P&R game it used to be, it's a brave new world, not my place to say whether it will be better or worse, time will tell on that one.
Post subject: Re: Salford placed in special measures
Posted: Fri Nov 24, 2023 5:21 pm
The Avenger
International Star
Joined: Mar 07 2014 Posts: 5070
vastman wrote:I get your point but I'm not sure about that. If Salford fail to start this season, and the IMG system doesn't start until 2025, then past protocol is that the demoted team regains it's place by default.
Also think it's fair to say that we may well soon overhaul Toulouse in the ratings, as those I believe were provisional. The Toulouse buy ou,t last I heard, had not yet gone through.
Just thinking out loud, but after a frenzied start, the signings have died down completely - maybe we are holding fire, just in case. I suspect someone like Ellis will know the situation Salford are really in better than most, seems to do his research.
However it needs sorting, because whoever replaces Salford should the worst occur, are quickly running out of time.
Certainly not the simple P&R game it used to be, it's a brave new world, not my place to say whether it will be better or worse, time will tell on that one.
Actually, I agree with you The best case is that Salford don’t go under but if they’re going to it needs sorting asap and if we’re being honest, Wakefield are by far the best club to replace them
Post subject: Re: Salford placed in special measures
Posted: Fri Nov 24, 2023 6:25 pm
PopTart
Moderator
Joined: Oct 04 2008 Posts: 21001 Location: wakefield
The Avenger wrote:Actually, I agree with you The best case is that Salford don’t go under but if they’re going to it needs sorting asap and if we’re being honest, Wakefield are by far the best club to replace them
But that changes our season. We are set for big crowds watching a lot of wins and building a feel good. If we were promoted again we'd have a team that would hardly compete and be watching a lot of beatings again before we are prepared to take them on.
A dog is not considered a good dog because he is a good barker. A man is not considered a good man because he is a good talker - Buddha
Post subject: Re: Salford placed in special measures
Posted: Fri Nov 24, 2023 6:36 pm
The Avenger
International Star
Joined: Mar 07 2014 Posts: 5070
PopTart wrote:But that changes our season. We are set for big crowds watching a lot of wins and building a feel good. If we were promoted again we'd have a team that would hardly compete and be watching a lot of beatings again before we are prepared to take them on.
Well as in my first post, I think Toulouse are ahead of us using the criteria but I think we are best placed to actually do the job but I guess we’d get asked and have the opportunity to say no if we felt we were being sent like lambs to the slaughter. The extra money from SL would be an incentive as would the more exciting fixture list and possibly higher numbers of visiting fans, hospitality sales and sponsorships that come with playing in the top division.
I agree we’d have to bring in some top quality players but we’re not being coached by a novice who’s out of his depth anymore.
Post subject: Re: Salford placed in special measures
Posted: Fri Nov 24, 2023 7:14 pm
homme vaste
Club Captain
Joined: Jan 22 2018 Posts: 2807 Location: Tomorrowland
charlie wrote:Could be a shambolic SuperLeague next year, problems for Salford and London running a part time team.....
Rather be in the championship, looking forward to some exciting games again.
Agree, if SL approached us now to be in the league next year, I'd rather us turn it down, we are preparing well for the Championship next season and building for the future, we don't need to jeopardise that by singing to anyone else's tune.
Post subject: Re: Salford placed in special measures
Posted: Fri Nov 24, 2023 7:26 pm
Prince Buster
Club Coach
Joined: Oct 11 2004 Posts: 5315 Location: Orange street
The Avenger wrote:Well as in my first post, I think Toulouse are ahead of us using the criteria but I think we are best placed to actually do the job but I guess we’d get asked and have the opportunity to say no if we felt we were being sent like lambs to the slaughter. The extra money from SL would be an incentive as would the more exciting fixture list and possibly higher numbers of visiting fans, hospitality sales and sponsorships that come with playing in the top division.
I agree we’d have to bring in some top quality players but we’re not being coached by a novice who’s out of his depth anymore.
One or two people within the game are questioning how Tolouse got such an high rating compared to London as they seem extremely evenly matched in every IMG criteria. People are also saying there has been no auditing or verification of any sort regarding clubs information that was provided to IMG.
Clubs other than Salford have already started to feel the financial pinch of reduced funding. I dont think there would be an appetite to see Tolouse join them due to lack of support and further travel costs. Every penny seems to count nowadays.
Post subject: Re: Salford placed in special measures
Posted: Fri Nov 24, 2023 7:44 pm
dboy
Player Coach
Joined: Oct 12 2005 Posts: 4229 Location: Barnsley
Prince Buster wrote: Clubs other than Salford have already started to feel the financial pinch of reduced funding.
Salford aren't experiencing the pinch of reduced funding. They are feeling the impending swoop of the Grim Reaper from spending money they have never had.
It's not something that's "happening" to them, it's something they have created.
Users browsing this forum: Google Adsense [Bot], Spookisback and 54 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum