Egg Banjo wrote:They're not non-voting shares - they still entitle you to a percentage of the profit as a shareholder - which these from Trinity categorically do not.
Words have meanings, just because you want them to mean something else doesn't mean they do. What these from Trinity are, just like those from Salford, or those from Bradford and Trinity of old (etc) is a dressed up form of donation.

As I've said, if people are happy to donate - great

But let's not pretend that we have offered something different to what Salford offered but it's OK just because we did it

dboy wrote::lol: Salford don't return profits

PopTart wrote:So if you are happy for people to donate what's your problem? Everybody knew what it was. You seem to be the only one trying to make something of it.

Egg Banjo wrote:As I've said countless times, my issue is people pretending that the Salford version is a problem but when we did it then it's totally fine

PopTart wrote:No. You keep saying it's fake and immoral and you are wrong. It's nothing to do with Salford.

Egg Banjo wrote:I'm not wrong, you just haven't realised it yet.

PopTart wrote:They explained it to me. I understood. And donated money.
It seems you don't understand.

Your whole argument centres on the name they chose to call it.
Everybody but you seems to understand that the "share certificate has no value, gives no voting rights nor a share in the club.

Do you complain on behalf of all the Jaguar owners who only get a car?

Egg Banjo wrote:Do Jaguar tell you you're going to become a shareholder when you buy a car?

PopTart wrote:They say you are getting a Jaguar....and then explain it is actually a car
Some as we told people there was an offer mentioning Shares, and then explained what that meant. So everyone understood what the scheme was.

Still can't see your problem.

Egg Banjo wrote:So they don't say "Become a shareholder in JLR" but then when you give them money you just get the custom floor mats?