Boss Hog wrote:What tackle? All I saw was a deliberate shoulder charge. Oddly though his disciplinary charge was for a high shot, no specific mention of it being late, or a shoulder charge: https://www.rugby-league.com/governance/rules-and-regulations/disciplinary/disciplinary-case?case=14299

Boss Hog wrote:What tackle? All I saw was a deliberate shoulder charge. Oddly though his disciplinary charge was for a high shot, no specific mention of it being late, or a shoulder charge: https://www.rugby-league.com/governance/rules-and-regulations/disciplinary/disciplinary-case?case=14299

shinymcshine wrote:Oddly though his disciplinary charge was for a high shot, no specific mention of it being late, or a shoulder charge: https://www.rugby-league.com/governance/rules-and-regulations/disciplinary/disciplinary-case?case=14299 As other posters have stated, the disciplinary, like the RL hierarchy has sadly become a joke.

shinymcshine wrote:Oddly though his disciplinary charge was for a high shot, no specific mention of it being late, or a shoulder charge: https://www.rugby-league.com/governance/rules-and-regulations/disciplinary/disciplinary-case?case=14299 As other posters have stated, the disciplinary, like the RL hierarchy has sadly become a joke.

I wonder how many titles we would have won without the RFL and refs rigging things in favour of Saints.

and Wigan......at least one...big shout to Russell Smith... you f***ing c***

But that's not what he was charged with. The charge carried a 1, 2 or 3 game ban. Seeing as most players stay on the field and get their bans retrospectively and makinson got a red then 2 games seems fair in my opinion. Not that the disciplinary panel has ANY credibility after lineham's 3 game ban earlier this season which was the biggest joke I've seen in 35 years of watching RL.

I am aware of the charge that he appeared for the disciplinary panel for.

My post was about what I saw when watching the game on the TV.

Do you not think that it wasn`t a shoulder charge then?

About the same number that we have through paying off refs and cheating the Salary Cap.

None..it would still be saints Leeds or Wigan who'd win it