bentleyman wrote:I wouldn't disagree with ones they are showing but surely Fax v Sts is a must along with Leigh v Leeds stay safe

Hudd-Shay wrote:Without any bias Fax v St Helens was one of the all time classics. Surely that match has to be in the top five Challenge Cup Finals.

Tony Fax wrote:Disagree. Might have been for the closeness but I thought it was a dour affair lacking attacking quality.

charlie caroli wrote:What about a Fax v Leigh Challenge Cup Final 1921...?

Hudd-Shay wrote:Wow!

Tony Fax wrote:Wow indeed, I remember being fairly bored until the elation at the end of course. We only looked like scoring 3 times, and one of those was in touch!
That's not how I remember the match at all,I'll have to watch the video again. What I do recall is coming out of Wembley sort of stunned and empty, yet after the Wigan game the season after I almost felt happier. Very strange

I agree with the Leigh - v Leeds match, however. Weird watching defenders trying desperately to keep kicks from going into touch, and the scrums being contested is a sad loss to the sport, but I think it got to the stage where the refs were just constantly penalising for feeding which became quite irritating.