Post subject: Re: Dumb, dumber, dumber and dumber and Wolford
Posted: Sat Jun 29, 2019 5:56 am
REDWHITEANDBLUE
International Board Member
Joined: Jan 04 2003 Posts: 4934
willo109 wrote:Agree with everything apart from Murphy got done for stopping them taking a quick tap yet their guy kicks the ball away near the end after he penalises them yet no son binning, no consistency from the ref apart from being one-eyed, not blaming him for one minute, but I'm sick of watching mickey poor officials. They were there for the taking and as you muted the score after our first try and the one before half time were the game changes. Onwards and upwards to Salford
The rule is different the ball is dead and Murphy prevented time for a quick tap. Oh you didn't mention the Huddersfield player who had a paddy and threw the ball away after knocking on. We have had players binned for that not seen any other team suffer a binning as yet!
Post subject: Re: Dumb, dumber, dumber and dumber and Wolford
Posted: Sat Jun 29, 2019 6:59 am
jools
Player Coach
Joined: Jun 09 2011 Posts: 10464
Since when is dropping on a loose ball a penalty? We knock on, another man in front of him drops on the loose ball - see that all the time but no this ref gives a penalty for the man dropping on the ball being offside- First offences is the knock on so scrum down!
Post subject: Re: Dumb, dumber, dumber and dumber and Wolford
Posted: Sat Jun 29, 2019 7:55 am
snowie
International Chairman
jools wrote:Since when is dropping on a loose ball a penalty? We knock on, another man in front of him drops on the loose ball - see that all the time but no this ref gives a penalty for the man dropping on the ball being offside- First offences is the knock on so scrum down!
wow you really don't know the rules of the game at all do you, I'll try explain this simply. firstly it doesn't happen all the time, if you seen it done then the ref is at fault
your player has knocked which would lead to a scrum if he'd picked it up but it wasn't, it was then shudds player stood in front of him in an offside position which you admit to this, this then stops the play, had it been a Wakey player picking the ball up and not made any yardage a scrum would of been given, had the said player gained yardage play would of continued and advantage given. first offence is when both team players knock on on the same play
Post subject: Re: Dumb, dumber, dumber and dumber and Wolford
Posted: Sat Jun 29, 2019 12:00 pm
jools
Player Coach
Joined: Jun 09 2011 Posts: 10464
snowie wrote:wow you really don't know the rules of the game at all do you, I'll try explain this simply. firstly it doesn't happen all the time, if you seen it done then the ref is at fault
your player has knocked which would lead to a scrum if he'd picked it up but it wasn't, it was then shudds player stood in front of him in an offside position which you admit to this, this then stops the play, had it been a Wakey player picking the ball up and not made any yardage a scrum would of been given, had the said player gained yardage play would of continued and advantage given. first offence is when both team players knock on on the same play
by the way thanks for the points this season
Yeah those points we’ve given You have kept you from relegation. You should be grateful.
The first offence is the knock on, seen plenty of offside players prevent the opposition picking up the ball, and it’s never been given as a penalty. Ever.
Post subject: Re: Dumb, dumber, dumber and dumber and Wolford
Posted: Sat Jun 29, 2019 12:20 pm
wotsupcas
International Star
Joined: Mar 02 2014 Posts: 915
jools wrote:Yeah those points we’ve given You have kept you from relegation. You should be grateful.
The first offence is the knock on, seen plenty of offside players prevent the opposition picking up the ball, and it’s never been given as a penalty. Ever.
Really? You've never seen that ever? Happens on an almost weekly basis. You're making a bit of a fool of yourself
Post subject: Re: Dumb, dumber, dumber and dumber and Wolford
Posted: Sat Jun 29, 2019 12:25 pm
Joehudds
Club Captain
Joined: May 19 2018 Posts: 195
They’re correct don’t know why you’re arguing jools , I get it blaming the ref is an easy option but you have to realise we played awful and have been playing awful all season
Post subject: Re: Dumb, dumber, dumber and dumber and Wolford
Posted: Sat Jun 29, 2019 12:35 pm
jools
Player Coach
Joined: Jun 09 2011 Posts: 10464
Joehudds wrote:They’re correct don’t know why you’re arguing jools , I get it blaming the ref is an easy option but you have to realise we played awful and have been playing awful all season
I’m not saying that isn’t the rule- I’m saying it’s not usually penalised- happens regularly.
He chooses to penalise for that- but not a yellow card for a swinging arm with direct contact to the head.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 31 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
