Joined: Jan 30 2004 Posts: 4406 Location: Posh Bransholme
bonaire wrote:Its going to be a problem for us on Friday Miloudi just cant tackle and we will be doing a lot of tackling on Friday so for me he is out of the question for the full back spot Surprisingly Griffin has done well at Full back and although not the best defender in the world he is a better option. Faraimo played centre for the USA so we could move him and bring Talanoa in on the wing
Does the modern day fullback tackle? Usually when their is a break they have men either side for me although I agree Miloudi is a liability and isn't the greatest in D surely he must be given a chance.
Always the Optimist never the Pessimist. Glass Half full not half empty man me.
Ellam wrote:Does the modern day fullback tackle? Usually when their is a break they have men either side for me although I agree Miloudi is a liability and isn't the greatest in D surely he must be given a chance.
If you look at some of the last ditch tackles Jamie Shaul has made especially when he gets under the player and stops the grounding the answer is yes but i do understand where you are coming from. Part of why Hardaker is a top full back is his defence. As for Miloudi i think he has been given his chance several times and probably now is no longer in Radfords plans going forward
Joined: Mar 23 2018 Posts: 6675 Location: Kingston upon Hull
bonaire wrote:If you look at some of the last ditch tackles Jamie Shaul has made especially when he gets under the player and stops the grounding the answer is yes but i do understand where you are coming from. Part of why Hardaker is a top full back is his defence. As for Miloudi i think he has been given his chance several times and probably now is no longer in Radfords plans going forward
Not sure about that Bonaire, the French lad would make a good off half, he looks assured in this position. He offers something different, and has an explosive burst of pace from standing, as for loads of chances, perhaps not a fullback as he was a little found out there. Unfortunately for him his chance of playing in the halves is probably not going to happen, he is an enigma that’s for sure.
Joined: Mar 14 2003 Posts: 25860 Location: Back in Hull.
bonaire wrote:If you look at some of the last ditch tackles Jamie Shaul has made especially when he gets under the player and stops the grounding the answer is yes but i do understand where you are coming from. Part of why Hardaker is a top full back is his defence. As for Miloudi i think he has been given his chance several times and probably now is no longer in Radfords plans going forward
Has he been given enough chances?
Had a poor game against Cas on the wing, but I'd say overall in his limited appearances he has impressed.
If we need to play miloudi we'd be better putting him at stand off and kelly at FB IMO. Will be much better defensively and will still be in the mix in attack
That's about the least injuries we've had in a year. Only about half a team missing so progress
I presume mini will play as his wife was due to give birth hence not travelling to london but if she hasn't yet then a home game shouldn't be an issue.
I can see radford playing griffin at FB, moving faraimo to centre and putting the bin man on the wing
Had a poor game against Cas on the wing, but I'd say overall in his limited appearances he has impressed.
I'd give him a chance this week
He did have a poor game on the wing against Castleford but his best performances for the club have been on the wing. He is a liability at full back so cant see Radford giving him another chance. Looks like Griffin will be starting full back and as i said previously it would be easier to move Faraimo to centre where he has played for the USA and Talanoa returns to the wing. From the reserves we have available cant see any other option although Connor Wynne is fit again but cant see Radford playing a rookie at full back.
MGarbutt1986 wrote:is that a professional medical opinion, supported by facts, or just what you believe?
Concussion occurs when the brain moves extremely fast within the cranium. The knock to the head could fracture the skull or break the skin but it’s the actual motion of the impact. When boxers get cracked on the chin, again it’s the motion that causes the the concussion. The inside of the cranium is not smooth but it’s jagged to hold the brain which is also not smooth. The fast whipping motion causes the brain to move within the cranium which in turn gets damaged. Boxers mostly get hit about the face or side of the head and lots of brain injury can cause “punch drunk”, that’s the slow deliberate speech as if drunk. A skull cap will not save the brain getting damaged but protects the skin and the ears. The only way to offer head protection is to play with a crash hat like the yanks in their footy game, NFL.
Joined: Sep 23 2008 Posts: 1889 Location: Top of the East Stand
Plum Bob wrote:Concussion occurs when the brain moves extremely fast within the cranium. The knock to the head could fracture the skull or break the skin but it’s the actual motion of the impact. When boxers get cracked on the chin, again it’s the motion that causes the the concussion. The inside of the cranium is not smooth but it’s jagged to hold the brain which is also not smooth. The fast whipping motion causes the brain to move within the cranium which in turn gets damaged. Boxers mostly get hit about the face or side of the head and lots of brain injury can cause “punch drunk”, that’s the slow deliberate speech as if drunk. A skull cap will not save the brain getting damaged but protects the skin and the ears. The only way to offer head protection is to play with a crash hat like the yanks in their footy game, NFL.
Plum Bob wrote:Concussion occurs when the brain moves extremely fast within the cranium. The knock to the head could fracture the skull or break the skin but it’s the actual motion of the impact. When boxers get cracked on the chin, again it’s the motion that causes the the concussion. The inside of the cranium is not smooth but it’s jagged to hold the brain which is also not smooth. The fast whipping motion causes the brain to move within the cranium which in turn gets damaged. Boxers mostly get hit about the face or side of the head and lots of brain injury can cause “punch drunk”, that’s the slow deliberate speech as if drunk. A skull cap will not save the brain getting damaged but protects the skin and the ears. The only way to offer head protection is to play with a crash hat like the yanks in their footy game, NFL.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum