Post subject: Re: So, Friday predictions against KR?
Posted: Mon Jan 28, 2019 11:51 am
Bombed Out
International Star
Joined: Feb 21 2012 Posts: 1420
Wilde 3 wrote:Our gamebreaker players are missing, and we don't play a brand of rugby that puts us in a position to score tries. Barge overs, or a Shaul length of field break may be our options on Friday
That's exactly how I see it. We are usually the masters of our own demise. Poor edge defence coupled with no real attacking prowess. Coupled with a hardly inspiring pre-season.
Post subject: Re: So, Friday predictions against KR?
Posted: Mon Jan 28, 2019 11:58 am
Windy winger
Club Captain
Joined: Mar 13 2018 Posts: 468
Us by 4 in a forward dominated game with not much skill on show . Saying that not many teams play good rugby in the opening month due to the weather and been rusty .
Post subject: Re: So, Friday predictions against KR?
Posted: Mon Jan 28, 2019 1:12 pm
pmarrow
Player Coach
Joined: Sep 04 2006 Posts: 6345 Location: Hull
Wilde 3 wrote:Our gamebreaker players are missing, and we don't play a brand of rugby that puts us in a position to score tries. Barge overs, or a Shaul length of field break may be our options on Friday
I understand them concerns but have seen nothing from KR to suggest they are any different really. When they beat us last time they scored from a barge over and a poor kick, only scored two penalty kicks in the second half. They may have the slight edge but I don't understand the vast majority thinking we will get beat comfortably. They've hardly hammered the two championship teams in front of them in pre season.
Post subject: Re: So, Friday predictions against KR?
Posted: Mon Jan 28, 2019 1:33 pm
MGarbutt1986
Club Captain
Joined: Jan 25 2019 Posts: 783
pmarrow wrote:I understand them concerns but have seen nothing from KR to suggest they are any different really. When they beat us last time they scored from a barge over and a poor kick, only scored two penalty kicks in the second half. They may have the slight edge but I don't understand the vast majority thinking we will get beat comfortably. They've hardly hammered the two championship teams in front of them in pre season.
11 game losing streak and a hardly inspiring pre-season, that's why people think we will lose.
Post subject: Re: So, Friday predictions against KR?
Posted: Mon Jan 28, 2019 1:53 pm
HFC Boy
International Board Member
Joined: Nov 30 2002 Posts: 3524 Location: North Hull
Hull KR 36 Hull FC 10
HULL FC CHALLENGE CUP WINNERS 2005 GRAND FINALISTS 2006 CHALLENGE CUP FINALISTS 2008 CHALLENGE CUP FINALISTS 2013 CHALLENGE CUP WINNERS 2016 CHALLENGE CUP WINNERS 2017
Post subject: Re: So, Friday predictions against KR?
Posted: Mon Jan 28, 2019 3:08 pm
bonaire
International Star
Joined: Apr 04 2014 Posts: 7817
Sadly a comfortable HKR win A predicted left edge of Griffin and Dawson with Minichello all of whom have poor defence is a big weakness in our team. I expect Rovers will score in the first five minutes stretching our defence and this will be what they do all the game. Only Taylor in the forwards has the power to make a dent in their defence
Post subject: Re: So, Friday predictions against KR?
Posted: Mon Jan 28, 2019 3:13 pm
Chris71
Moderator
Joined: Jan 30 2004 Posts: 8221 Location: Never never land away with the fairies
MGarbutt1986 wrote:Think we will lose, just hope it's not an embarrassing defeat. (seriously hope I am wrong) but recruitment has been poor compared to other SL sides.
Whilst I'm not overly confident about Friday given that we have a lot of players coming back from long term injuries and are likely to be missing Connor & Kelly plus we are still missing the likes of Westerman, Bowden, Green etc, also the likes of Griffin and Paea still seemingly struggling with injury.
I think we certainly need to have more options/structures as an attacking threat than we have seen in the 3 pre season games and am hoping its been a case of keeping our powder dry during preseason than having made no changes to our attacking options.
We are far too reliant as has been said on tries from the boot of Sneyd or individual skill from Kelly/Connor or a break from Shaul, as we lack the ability to break teams down in the opposition's 20 and create openings. Which makes us far to predictable and easy to defend against.
Whilst some of what Schofield says is plausible for me any credible spouting he comes up with is shot down by classing Kleinhorst & Garbutt as quality signings, Kleinhorst couldn't get regular game time in the Rhinos squad that finished in the bottom 4 and Garbutt for me is ok but no better than say Huby and certainly not quality. Seems that if you played for Leeds you are automatically a quality player in Schofields head. Its yet to be seen how things will pan out this season with the changes to the game particularly with the reduction in interchanges. Are match day 17 squads going to carry a hooker or utility player just incase or go all out with forwards on the benches?
Too early to say how we will go but don't think the pre season has helped get the hopes up of a decent season as after attending all 3 pre season games nothing much has changed as in speed at which we play/move the ball, support play and options for the runner if a break is made was still awful and lacking and DISCIPLINE still not improved greatly.
MGarbutt1986 wrote:Think we will lose, just hope it's not an embarrassing defeat. (seriously hope I am wrong) but recruitment has been poor compared to other SL sides.
Whilst I'm not overly confident about Friday given that we have a lot of players coming back from long term injuries and are likely to be missing Connor & Kelly plus we are still missing the likes of Westerman, Bowden, Green etc, also the likes of Griffin and Paea still seemingly struggling with injury.
I think we certainly need to have more options/structures as an attacking threat than we have seen in the 3 pre season games and am hoping its been a case of keeping our powder dry during preseason than having made no changes to our attacking options.
We are far too reliant as has been said on tries from the boot of Sneyd or individual skill from Kelly/Connor or a break from Shaul, as we lack the ability to break teams down in the opposition's 20 and create openings. Which makes us far to predictable and easy to defend against.
Whilst some of what Schofield says is plausible for me any credible spouting he comes up with is shot down by classing Kleinhorst & Garbutt as quality signings, Kleinhorst couldn't get regular game time in the Rhinos squad that finished in the bottom 4 and Garbutt for me is ok but no better than say Huby and certainly not quality. Seems that if you played for Leeds you are automatically a quality player in Schofields head. Its yet to be seen how things will pan out this season with the changes to the game particularly with the reduction in interchanges. Are match day 17 squads going to carry a hooker or utility player just incase or go all out with forwards on the benches?
Too early to say how we will go but don't think the pre season has helped get the hopes up of a decent season as after attending all 3 pre season games nothing much has changed as in speed at which we play/move the ball, support play and options for the runner if a break is made was still awful and lacking and DISCIPLINE still not improved greatly.
I really enjoy long walks especially when they are taken by people I don't like!
Post subject: Re: So, Friday predictions against KR?
Posted: Mon Jan 28, 2019 3:42 pm
bonaire
International Star
Joined: Apr 04 2014 Posts: 7817
Chris71 wrote:Whilst I'm not overly confident about Friday given that we have a lot of players coming back from long term injuries and are likely to be missing Connor & Kelly plus we are still missing the likes of Westerman, Bowden, Green etc, also the likes of Griffin and Paea still seemingly struggling with injury.
I think we certainly need to have more options/structures as an attacking threat than we have seen in the 3 pre season games and am hoping its been a case of keeping our powder dry during preseason than having made no changes to our attacking options.
We are far too reliant as has been said on tries from the boot of Sneyd or individual skill from Kelly/Connor or a break from Shaul, as we lack the ability to break teams down in the opposition's 20 and create openings. Which makes us far to predictable and easy to defend against.
Whilst some of what Schofield says is plausible for me any credible spouting he comes up with is shot down by classing Kleinhorst & Garbutt as quality signings, Kleinhorst couldn't get regular game time in the Rhinos squad that finished in the bottom 4 and Garbutt for me is ok but no better than say Huby and certainly not quality. Seems that if you played for Leeds you are automatically a quality player in Schofields head. Its yet to be seen how things will pan out this season with the changes to the game particularly with the reduction in interchanges. Are match day 17 squads going to carry a hooker or utility player just incase or go all out with forwards on the benches?
Too early to say how we will go but don't think the pre season has helped get the hopes up of a decent season as after attending all 3 pre season games nothing much has changed as in speed at which we play/move the ball, support play and options for the runner if a break is made was still awful and lacking and DISCIPLINE still not improved greatly.
Its the reason we should be pointing the finger at Radford because despite all the reported hard work of the coaching staff we fans see nothing that has changed in our play and the indiscipline which is something the coaches can eliminate has still not improved. Without doubt Radford will go for four forwards on the bench. On a positive note our fitness has gone up a level this pre season and may help us stay in some close games.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
