vastman wrote:Something he’s not yet mentioned is Tom Johnstone rather brilliant try. This is the same Tom who he’d rather have Ourvan over yet the apparantly out of form Tom beat half their team - when did Ourvan ever do thatcertanly not in a Widnes shirt
I will hold my hands up and say he was brilliant yesterday. I guess when you don`t see a player week in week out it is quite easy to say to those who rate him that he is over rated . Sometimes you catch a player have a under par performance and start to form an opinion on that but as I say yesterday he was brilliant.
Joined: Oct 13 2004 Posts: 36083 Location: Poodle Power!
ScouseViking wrote:I will hold my hands up and say he was brilliant yesterday. I guess when you don`t see a player week in week out it is quite easy to say to those who rate him that he is over rated . Sometimes you catch a player have a under par performance and start to form an opinion on that but as I say yesterday he was brilliant.
You're still a mile out regarding our props. The only prop we have that's remotely similar to yours is Hirst and he's improving fast and is probably on far less dosh than some of yours.
The two brothers look OK but too suggest either are anywhere near Fifita come on - Dave may be slightly over rated I'm not sure but he's still one of the most destructive runners in SL.
Johnstone v Ourvan rubbish aside, I would struggle to bag Ourvan for anything, he's a big solid tackle busting lump that knows how to finish, I wouldn't at all be put out by the thought of him being a Wakey player. The Chuckle Brothers though....well, I think we've moved on, a couple of seasons ago maybe they'd have been a decent fit, but these day's its tough to see past what we already have.
Joined: Oct 13 2004 Posts: 36083 Location: Poodle Power!
Upanunder wrote:Johnstone v Ourvan rubbish aside, I would struggle to bag Ourvan for anything, he's a big solid tackle busting lump that knows how to finish, I wouldn't at all be put out by the thought of him being a Wakey player. The Chuckle Brothers though....well, I think we've moved on, a couple of seasons ago maybe they'd have been a decent fit, but these day's its tough to see past what we already have.
It’s not rubbish is it, he’s not a patch on either of our wingers and signing him certainly wouldn’t please me but each to there own.
vastman wrote:It’s not rubbish is it, he’s not a patch on either of our wingers and signing him certainly wouldn’t please me but each to there own.
Yeah its rubbish, its hypothetical bunk, they are 2 different players with a completely different strengths, and neither are available so its Monday night fantasy argument. The quality of both players and what they bring is tangible, it would be silly to dismiss either.
Joined: Oct 13 2004 Posts: 36083 Location: Poodle Power!
Upanunder wrote:Yeah its rubbish, its hypothetical bunk, they are 2 different players with a completely different strengths, and neither are available so its Monday night fantasy argument. The quality of both players and what they bring is tangible, it would be silly to dismiss either.
Except when you do it of course, give it a rest yourr not the coaching genius you seem to think you are. You rate the big lump then fine but not everybody has to agree with you - and on this case that includes me!!
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
