If Radford and Pearson think he is the right man for the job, then we have to trust them, done a pretty good job with decisions the last few years

I don't think giving him a position based on sentiment is a sensible way to go. He should be taken on because he has the right character & professionalism and is ultimately good at what he does & will improve the current setup. I've seen nothing in his coaching career to suggest he's any of those things.

Well there isn't a job really, just a role created by fans because we feel our attack needs improvement.

We all make our choices in life Paul Cook made his 10 years ago. IF Hull Fc employ Paul Cook I will not be renewing mine or my grandchildren's passes that is my choice

Jesus.

from Judas to Jesus!!

(agree, huge overreaction to say they'd cancel a pass)

That's in your opinion just like Tooms2000 is entitled to have theirs and make a decision of their choosing.

Just like some people would still have Schofield burnt at the stake for something that happened 30 years ago

I'd have him back if I thought he had anything to offer. Having read his column in the HDM and heard his punditry on the radio and TV I'd say he knows nothing about rugby you couldn't pick up from reading the Wikipedia page on it.

Nothing to do with sentiment, my comments were about his motivation.

Leigh, in the championship and middle 8 of 2016 were sensational in attack. Given they were going to be one of the weaker teams in SL, its harsh to judge Cooke on 2017.

I really feel sorry for your grand children that they have you in their family tree.