PCollinson1990 wrote:I don't mention him because of the results, I make comment because he's not a very good referee, for any team.
Well thankfully he called the Clubb no try correctly by saying there was no clear pulling action on the ball by Tuimavave. I would argue some video refs would have awarded that try even though the referee quite rightly said no try.
bonaire wrote:Well thankfully he called the Clubb no try correctly by saying there was no clear pulling action on the ball by Tuimavave. I would argue some video refs would have awarded that try even though the referee quite rightly said no try.
They rarely overturn the decision of the referee, they have to feel there's good reason.
the artist wrote:Leeds first game without the south stand open of course. wonder where the drum will be located?
Up the drummer's 4rse hopefully
I'm surprised radford isn't resting more players TBH. I just can't see us getting anything from Thursday's game and it would have been better to rest a few and prepare properly for the wigan game IMO
bonaire wrote:Well thankfully he called the Clubb no try correctly by saying there was no clear pulling action on the ball by Tuimavave. I would argue some video refs would have awarded that try even though the referee quite rightly said no try.
I agree was the correct decision. But is it our black and white tinted glasses or what! Really surprised that all commentary thought it should of been a try, and every other person i speak to does (non hull supporters) Just dont see it at all, in that position he should of really been keeping hold of that ball, no obvious pulling the ball out, lose carry for me, correct decision
All very light workouts right up to KO. Hope the batteries can get charged up enough to last the 80. We will be fired up for this and targetting a win.
Joined: Jun 28 2002 Posts: 11184 Location: Castleford
Tinkerman23 wrote:I agree was the correct decision. But is it our black and white tinted glasses or what! Really surprised that all commentary thought it should of been a try, and every other person i speak to does (non hull supporters) Just dont see it at all, in that position he should of really been keeping hold of that ball, no obvious pulling the ball out, lose carry for me, correct decision
My hubby commentated on Radio Yorkshire on Saturday and said live that it was a loose carry. Then again, he's as anti Wigan as me so that's probably not the best example!
Black 'n' White's Best Female 2006 & Runner Up 2007 & 2008 "We will not accept a top eight finish as a barometer of supposed success at any point in the future whilst I am the owner of this club", A Pearson 23/09/2011
Joined: Mar 21 2017 Posts: 159 Location: Back to God's own country!
Karen wrote:My hubby commentated on Radio Yorkshire on Saturday and said live that it was a loose carry. Then again, he's as anti Wigan as me so that's probably not the best example!
I'm as passionate as any FC fan, but pride myself on being able to look at incidents objectively. I was shocked at the BBC pundits (and many other people since) saying that it should have been a try. No matter what team and what opponents, that was NEVER a strip of the ball!
"If the human brain were so simple that we could understand it, we would be so simple that we couldn't." - Emerson M. Pugh
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum