cas all the way wrote:You are wrong. The ball doesn't have to be propelled forward. It can go slightly forward and sideways.... As it was sent up as no try there is no clear evidence it went back. You can't complain with that.
rodney_trotter wrote:I think we lacked composure tonight and neither team played to their potential. I'm not disappointed with the effort but it's a shame we gifted them their first try. Apart from that it was a good game and we nearly sneaked it. Some of our first teamers getting unnecessary stick as per usual on this forum and it's more like a crèche on here sometimes. If the team doesn't play as well as we can do, then it seems unfair to pin the blame on individual players. I understand people blaming the red because they are upset with the result but they really need to look closer to home because it was not his fault we lost tonight
Sorry but for someone who rarely criticises officials, in this case, if he'd signalled "Try" on the field, it would have been allowed upstairs.
Joined: Jan 28 2005 Posts: 3098 Location: advertising my villa
classov78 wrote:the problem i have with it is that mcshane tackled mini b4 he was passed to and as minni was never in posession it should have been a hull penalty if try is disallowed
If true then I agree. Penalty should have been given but I was too busy watching the ball to notice.
Anyway as said earlier. 3 major close games so far but you definitely have the edge on us at present. I do worry about meeting you in the play offs. More so than anyone else.
Joined: Jul 15 2005 Posts: 29811 Location: West Yorkshire
knockersbumpMKII wrote:well done you but actually no. You might as well have saved your money or just left at halftime because you wrote the team off again when there is no need to. Do you just go as some sort or perverse ritual so you can then come out with the nonsense you do pretty much every game?
I went to the game to cheer the team on in hope of a close game but realistic enough to appreciate the magnitude of the task. Was very exciting at fhe end so delighted to have been there in person to lend some actual vocal support although clearly the damage was done by half time. Plenty of positive to take although need to try and hold 4th.
Joined: Mar 14 2003 Posts: 25977 Location: Back in Hull.
cas all the way wrote:You are wrong. The ball doesn't have to be propelled forward. It can go slightly forward and sideways.... As it was sent up as no try there is no clear evidence it went back. You can't complain with that.
Ball went backwards, video ref can overturn it and it should have, can't blame it for the loss as, even if given anything could have happen in the last 10.
Need to get rid of the ref call, worst rule at the moment
Joined: Jan 28 2005 Posts: 3098 Location: advertising my villa
Tinkerman23 wrote:Your joking right?
No..... You are anyone else can not say that clearly went backwards. It hit his arm, he ran forwards and the ball landed roughly the same area where it hit him. Meaning it's a knock on. I've watched it 5 times over now and there is no clear evidence it went back. Meaning the decision could not be overturned.
Joined: Jul 15 2005 Posts: 29811 Location: West Yorkshire
cas all the way wrote:If true then I agree. Penalty should have been given but I was too busy watching the ball to notice.
Anyway as said earlier. 3 major close games so far but you definitely have the edge on us at present. I do worry about meeting you in the play offs. More so than anyone else.
Chris Irvine saying we both look like Grand Finalists. Goodness me.
Joined: Mar 14 2003 Posts: 25977 Location: Back in Hull.
Play with that intensity but a bit smarter and we win the next 4 games,be 2nd in the league and at Wembley, no other team we play are anywhere as good as Cas.
Last edited by Dave K. on Fri Jun 30, 2017 9:53 pm, edited 1 time in total.
cas all the way wrote:No..... You are anyone else can not say that clearly went backwards. It hit his arm, he ran forwards and the ball landed roughly the same area where it hit him. Meaning it's a knock on. I've watched it 5 times over now and there is no clear evidence it went back. Meaning the decision could not be overturned.
It hit the top of his shoulder and carried on the same direction it was thrown , backwards! I think your having a laugh
Joined: Jan 28 2005 Posts: 3098 Location: advertising my villa
Dave K. wrote:Play we that intensity next but a bit smarter and we win the next 4 games,be 2nd in the league and at Wembley, no other team we play are anywhere as good as Cas.
You definitely are the best team we have played. The only team who has stopped us playing our usual game. Outplaying us in the forwards each match too.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
