Post subject: Re: HULL FC v CASTLEFORD TIGERS - Sunday 23rd.
Posted: Mon Apr 24, 2017 11:49 am
Dave K.
International Board Member
Joined: Mar 14 2003 Posts: 25935 Location: Back in Hull.
Just looked at the stats, unbelievable effort to win that game, they had nearly 10 more sets, 3 times as many offloads as us, somehow we made more breaks than them.
Some good meters made from nearly all the forwards, lots of missed tackle but you would exepct that given the circumstances, but the cover defence was outstanding.
Post subject: Re: HULL FC v CASTLEFORD TIGERS - Sunday 23rd.
Posted: Mon Apr 24, 2017 2:03 pm
Sheephead
Player Coach
Joined: Jun 18 2007 Posts: 115
From what I've seen of the highlights (wasn't at the game) all of cas's try were defensive errors,
Minilkin try had Sneyd Taylor and Shaul around him and at least one of them should of made a tackle on him
Ben Roberts try (maybe short by some social media posts) if we let him up to play there didn't get someone behind the POTB til late also miss tackle from Ellis and Green.
Shentons try is missed tackles by Thomo and Sneyd
Roberts second Carlos ball watching
And McMeeken try is out numbered on the edge which with 12 men in the last minute could be excused
I'm not having a go at the team cos it was a good defensive effort all round but I still think we need to tweak tho little things if we're are going to be serious title contenders
Post subject: Re: HULL FC v CASTLEFORD TIGERS - Sunday 23rd.
Posted: Mon Apr 24, 2017 2:08 pm
Irregs#16
Player Coach
Joined: Jul 05 2006 Posts: 8623
Sheephead wrote:From what I've seen of the highlights (wasn't at the game) all of cas's try were defensive errors,
Minilkin try had Sneyd Taylor and Shaul around him and at least one of them should of made a tackle on him
Ben Roberts try (maybe short by some social media posts) if we let him up to play there didn't get someone behind the POTB til late also miss tackle from Ellis and Green.
Shentons try is missed tackles by Thomo and Sneyd
Roberts second Carlos ball watching
And McMeeken try is out numbered on the edge which with 12 men in the last minute could be excused
I'm not having a go at the team cos it was a good defensive effort all round but I still think we need to tweak tho little things if we're are going to be serious title contenders
Tries like that irritate me. 3 players chasing across, if just one of them backs off and anticipates the step back on the inside then the tackle is made.
davey37 wrote:Then that is ridiculous. You have to use some common sense. Not something referees are blessed with granted.
But how many times do we see accidental clash of heads.
Going by that rule it should be a penalty. But who too?
Contact with the head while making the tackle, i.e. arm hitting his head. Clash of heads is not a head high tackle. We've had that rule for quite some time I believe, and it's quite right as well. You haven't been tackled fairly. But if completely accidental and not reckless or malicious, a penalty is all it should be in my opinion. Some promote the idea that head highs should be an automatic yellow.
If you are interested in Building Information Modelling (BIM). PM me.
Post subject: Re: HULL FC v CASTLEFORD TIGERS - Sunday 23rd.
Posted: Mon Apr 24, 2017 2:22 pm
bonaire
International Star
Joined: Apr 04 2014 Posts: 7841
Bal wrote:Contact with the head while making the tackle, i.e. arm hitting his head. Clash of heads is not a head high tackle. We've had that rule for quite some time I believe, and it's quite right as well. You haven't been tackled fairly. But if completely accidental and not reckless or malicious, a penalty is all it should be in my opinion. Some promote the idea that head highs should be an automatic yellow.
I wonder what the charge against Watts will be as it cant be classed as a head high tackle in the true sense. The fact that the player is falling and photos clearly show his head is at the level of Watts top leg and his arm is still at his side. Has to be sending off sufficient for me. Im more concerned about what Kelly is on report for.
Post subject: Re: HULL FC v CASTLEFORD TIGERS - Sunday 23rd.
Posted: Mon Apr 24, 2017 2:41 pm
Irregs#16
Player Coach
Joined: Jul 05 2006 Posts: 8623
bonaire wrote:I wonder what the charge against Watts will be as it cant be classed as a head high tackle in the true sense. The fact that the player is falling and photos clearly show his head is at the level of Watts top leg and his arm is still at his side. Has to be sending off sufficient for me. Im more concerned about what Kelly is on report for.
A bite apparently. But I dont recall Gale showing his arm (or wherever he claims to have been bitten) to the ref, so how it is proved I have no idea
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum