1 vote for this category please. i'll start the thread for the prop positions tomorrow

Astounded Tommy Finn hasn't made this list, my Grandad will be turning in his grave.

Wow that's spooky was just posting the same.11 seasons, Three Championship Finals, two Wembley finals, two Yorkshire Cup Finals 375 games and 132 tries? AND star of the Grandstand opening credits for several years! Great player!

My Grandad used to tell me he was the most underrated player (mainly due to the quality in the team during that period) of his time, and he should have played Internationally.

Yeh well know comment amongst the Fc fans back then but sadly an era of outstanding scrum halves none the least being the great Alex Murphy.

to be fair i put it out about tommy finn's inclusion in the nominees thread, but nobody got back to me so i went with the original 5 - if nobody comments at the time then i can't include them

so far it doesn't look like affecting the result though

I put forward a motion to re-open nominations.

i'll need to know which of the 5 he should replace - adding a player needs to be balanced by leaving someone out - my gut feeling was finn for entat

i've gone with my gut feeling and put finn in the 5 for entat

Sorry it's taken me so long to reply, yes I agree with this move.

Having voted and seen the result, I'm sure it won't make a difference!


Shame these older guys are getting over looked for someone who played for the club for a fraction of the time and didn't achieve half as much.
I think there's a subtle difference between the greatest players for the club and best players to play for the club.