What's the dilemma? Hall may well have got three tries last week, but Briscoe has started the season far better than him, and BJB last two performances have been better than both (despite not as good a player IMO). Therefore you drop Hall.

RYAN HALL: 5 Tries, 5 Appearances

TOM BRISCOE: 5 Tries, 5 Appearances

BEN JONES-BISHOP: 4 Tries, 2 Appearances

KALLUM WATKINS: 4 Tries, 6 Appearances

ZAK HARDAKER: 4 Tries, 6 Appearances

JOEL MOON: 2 Tries, 5 Appearances

Given he is both recovering from an injury, and our least prolific outside back, I'd say drop Moon.

Hall is the best winger at the club and his form has returned. Briscoe started like a house on fire (outside Watkins) but in his last outing (outside Moon, Ablett and Ward) was poor. He's still the second best winger at the club. BJB has been excellent in his two games outside Watkins, He's still the third best winger at the club.

For me the decision is easy and it's simply do I select BJB at left centre ahead of Moon, if Moon's fit, or do i leave BJB out.

Does it matter who gets left out???

I really think we missed the chance to see BJB or Briscoe at centre last Friday. If our coach wants to keep Ablett in the pack then it was obvious (IMO) to look at the option of one of those two in that position. You don't want to move Hardaker to centre (although I have a horrible feeling we will see that happen this week) and we have two centres who are at some point going to pick up knocks or need a rest. Ward was just a dumb idea (sorry Brian, but it was).

Stains fans already making excuses for the match. Reading some of their posts you would think they are down at the botom of the league rather than top. What a positive bunch they are!

they have a point though.dont think there would be such an air of positvity going into this game around these parts if we had the likes of Sinfield,Watkins,JP,Kylie,Burrow and a couple more front line players missing,which is equivalant to Saints losses this week.

I will take the win if it comes now, as it should.But as I stated elsewhere,would much prefer both teams to be full strength.

In your opinion, on both counts.

If Moon isn't fully fit then he should miss out with either Bjb or Briscoe at LC imo.
If Moon plays then again imo Bjb misses out.

at a similar last year we played Saints away. I remember Moon and Hall combining nicely for a lovely score.

A year down the line has their combination progressed?