Rupert Pupkin wrote:Good steady player, good enough to be at a top club, not at all.
Agree with that. says it all though about our options in the halves again that I would still be pleased if we sign him though.
Carvell a different cup of tea. Still top class and will make a huge difference to our pack and go-forward. The only concern would be the balance of the front row if we do sign him as we will have quite some size and go-forward but we wont be able to rely on big minutes from either Carvell, Paea or Feka so a big decision on who is fourth prop as they will likely have to spend a lot of time out there.
Joined: Mar 14 2003 Posts: 25757 Location: Back in Hull.
jimmys sidestep wrote:Agree with that. says it all though about our options in the halves again that I would still be pleased if we sign him though.
Carvell a different cup of tea. Still top class and will make a huge difference to our pack and go-forward. The only concern would be the balance of the front row if we do sign him as we will have quite some size and go-forward but we wont be able to rely on big minutes from either Carvell, Paea or Feka so a big decision on who is fourth prop as they will likely have to spend a lot of time out there.
Green. Also as long as the substitutions are done correctly, it won't be a concern.
Hopefully the deal will go through soon, so that he cam play on Friday.
Just looked at Gale and Miller stats from last season, millers are much better in the attacking sense.
Joined: Jan 10 2007 Posts: 6766 Location: Stalking Jerry Langford
jimmys sidestep wrote:Agree with that. says it all though about our options in the halves again that I would still be pleased if we sign him though.
Carvell a different cup of tea. Still top class and will make a huge difference to our pack and go-forward. The only concern would be the balance of the front row if we do sign him as we will have quite some size and go-forward but we wont be able to rely on big minutes from either Carvell, Paea or Feka so a big decision on who is fourth prop as they will likely have to spend a lot of time out there.
Carvell is a good player, still has it and I was hugely surprised he was allowed to leave Warrington, especially as they have had many ageing players in their squad over recent years. I think FC are pretty weak up front but this signing will certainly address that.
I don't see it as a job. It is a passion and love that we all share. Neil Hudgell
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
