FORUMS FORUMS




  

Home TV, Film, Youtube, Streaming Band Of Brothers



Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 33 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next
Author Message
 Post subject: Re: Band Of Brothers
PostPosted: Fri Jan 25, 2013 6:24 pm 
Club Coach
Club Coach
User avatar

Joined: Mar 24 2010
Posts: 15521
Location: Ossett
vastman wrote:Hated it from start to finish. Historically inaccurate in the extreme with no reference to the other "Allies" in the war - something the yanks have a real inability to do.

Worse than Private Ryan which I thought an impossibility.

Jingoistic sentimental crud which the fantastic action scenes could not even save.

Sorry guys but I really don't like either of them, but the wife does if that helps :D


I'm with you on the US tendency to re-write history, particularly in film; Braveheart, and U571 being particularly egregious examples.

Was BoB guilty of the same crimes, or did it just focus on US units, to follow their stories and create a narrative? I'm not familiar with the facts of the conflicts that were featured in the series in sufficient detail to form a view, so it's a genuine question.

Top
   
 
 Post subject: Re: Band Of Brothers
PostPosted: Fri Jan 25, 2013 7:13 pm 
Club Coach
Club Captain
User avatar

Joined: Oct 07 2004
Posts: 3325
Location: Leeds
bren2k wrote:I'm with you on the US tendency to re-write history, particularly in film; Braveheart, and U571 being particularly egregious examples.

Was BoB guilty of the same crimes, or did it just focus on US units, to follow their stories and create a narrative? I'm not familiar with the facts of the conflicts that were featured in the series in sufficient detail to form a view, so it's a genuine question.



It followed the US units. I'd highly recommend you give it a go to judge for yourself, too. :)






"In this age of Rooney and Tevez, here is a genuine, through and through sporting hero." Kevin Sinfield

I've got diamonds on my fish.

Top
   
 
 Post subject: Re: Band Of Brothers
PostPosted: Fri Jan 25, 2013 7:51 pm 
Club Coach
Club Coach
User avatar

Joined: Mar 24 2010
Posts: 15521
Location: Ossett
Steve-O wrote:It followed the US units. I'd highly recommend you give it a go to judge for yourself, too. :)


I have - watched it ages ago and loved it.

Top
   
 
 Post subject: Re: Band Of Brothers
PostPosted: Fri Jan 25, 2013 8:06 pm 
Club Coach
Club Captain
User avatar

Joined: Oct 07 2004
Posts: 3325
Location: Leeds
bren2k wrote:I have - watched it ages ago and loved it.


Ah I wasn't sure if you were asking the question as someone who hadn't seen it. I can't believe it took me so long to get around to it.

It's what I seem to do with all TV shows really though..






"In this age of Rooney and Tevez, here is a genuine, through and through sporting hero." Kevin Sinfield

I've got diamonds on my fish.

Top
   
 
 Post subject: Re: Band Of Brothers
PostPosted: Sun Feb 17, 2013 1:01 pm 
Player Coach
Club Captain
User avatar

Joined: May 15 2006
Posts: 2912
bren2k wrote:I'm with you on the US tendency to re-write history, particularly in film; Braveheart, and U571 being particularly egregious examples.

Was BoB guilty of the same crimes, or did it just focus on US units, to follow their stories and create a narrative? I'm not familiar with the facts of the conflicts that were featured in the series in sufficient detail to form a view, so it's a genuine question.


It was the story of a group of volunteer US airbourne troops and to my limited knowledge historically accurate and in my opinion far from jingoistic.

There is one scene where the US troops are sent to escort British Paratroopers from Arnem back to safety. The two commanders meet up at night and the US commander asks the British one where his troops are. The US guy is stunned as with a signal hundreds of British paratroopers emerge from all around. To me that was tribute to the skill and fieldcraft of the British forces that were within feet of the the US airbourne unit, who didn't even know they were there.

Ambrose had already written a book on UK Airbourne forces (Pegasus Bridge) and Band of Brothers was intended as telling the story of Airbourne forces contribution in WW2 from the US perspective.

For me it is one of the finest TV series ever.






www.hullrockers.co.uk

Top
   
 
 Post subject: Re: Band Of Brothers
PostPosted: Mon Feb 18, 2013 3:14 pm 
Club Coach
International Star
User avatar

Joined: Jan 30 2005
Posts: 7152
Location: one day closer to death
vastman wrote:Hated it from start to finish. Historically inaccurate in the extreme with no reference to the other "Allies" in the war - something the yanks have a real inability to do.

Worse than Private Ryan which I thought an impossibility.

Jingoistic sentimental crud which the fantastic action scenes could not even save.

Sorry guys but I really don't like either of them, but the wife does if that helps :D

Seeing as it's based on accounts of the experiences of Easy Company of the 101st as related by the veterans and in conjunction with historical records and other autobiographies, it's actually considered to be very accurate and is pretty highly regarded by the troops themselves. It's not a wide account of the Allies during the campaign, but a close examination of a small group of men - there is no reason to mention other Allies much at all.

Private Ryan, of the other hand, was indeed over-hyped and over-dramatic according to many veterans.

I would absolutely urge anyone planning on watching Band of Brothers for the first time to read the Ambrose book first. It delivers far more insight and allows you to relate to the characters of the TV series far more deeply.

That said, Ambrose didn't actually think much of the British soldier in WWII. His view was that the British were exhausted by 1944 and were still marked by the horrendous losses of WWI - therefore less willing to expose themselves to danger or take risks, whereas the Americans were 'fresh' and made more impressive advances due to their relative lack of exposure to the dangers - and of course they had Patton driving the Third Army forward. He felt that the war could have ended earlier had the British pushed themselves as the Americans did.

Top
   
 
 Post subject: Re: Band Of Brothers
PostPosted: Tue Feb 19, 2013 11:04 am 
Club Coach
Player Coach
User avatar

Joined: Jan 15 2005
Posts: 12434
Location: Hull
I love to see Pegasus Bridge made into a movie .

Top
   
 
 Post subject: Re: Band Of Brothers
PostPosted: Tue Feb 19, 2013 7:07 pm 
International Star
Junior Player
User avatar

Joined: Jul 20 2011
Posts: 117
One of the finest things ever put to film for me. The book is also a thoroughly good read. I have watched The Pacific and enjoyed it although I have never felt inclined to re-watch it where as I re-watch BoB at least a couple of times a year.

If you haven't seen it watch out for early roles for such (now) Hollywood luminaries as Tom Hardy, Michael Fassbender and James McAvoy.

Top
   
 
 Post subject: Re: Band Of Brothers
PostPosted: Tue Feb 26, 2013 10:49 pm 
Club Owner
First Team Player
User avatar

Joined: Dec 09 2003
Posts: 1429
Location: Kingston upon Hull(FC)
Barnacle Bill wrote:It was the story of a group of volunteer US airbourne troops and to my limited knowledge historically accurate and in my opinion far from jingoistic.

There is one scene where the US troops are sent to escort British Paratroopers from Arnem back to safety. The two commanders meet up at night and the US commander asks the British one where his troops are. The US guy is stunned as with a signal hundreds of British paratroopers emerge from all around. To me that was tribute to the skill and fieldcraft of the British forces that were within feet of the the US airbourne unit, who didn't even know they were there.

Ambrose had already written a book on UK Airbourne forces (Pegasus Bridge) and Band of Brothers was intended as telling the story of Airbourne forces contribution in WW2 from the US perspective.

For me it is one of the finest TV series ever.


Apparently and according to Ambrose... a US officer said of the above(British planned) operation you wouldn't want a limey in the trench next to you but they were bloody good planners.






Whoever stands by a just cause and fights for the freedom and liberation of his land from the invaders, the settlers and the colonialists, cannot possibly be called terrorist."

— Yasser Arafat

Top
   
 
 Post subject: Re: Band Of Brothers
PostPosted: Tue Feb 26, 2013 10:56 pm 
Club Owner
First Team Player
User avatar

Joined: Dec 09 2003
Posts: 1429
Location: Kingston upon Hull(FC)
Barnacle Bill wrote:It was the story of a group of volunteer US airbourne troops and to my limited knowledge historically accurate and in my opinion far from jingoistic.

There is one scene where the US troops are sent to escort British Paratroopers from Arnem back to safety. The two commanders meet up at night and the US commander asks the British one where his troops are. The US guy is stunned as with a signal hundreds of British paratroopers emerge from all around. To me that was tribute to the skill and fieldcraft of the British forces that were within feet of the the US airbourne unit, who didn't even know they were there.

Ambrose had already written a book on UK Airbourne forces (Pegasus Bridge) and Band of Brothers was intended as telling the story of Airbourne forces contribution in WW2 from the US perspective.

For me it is one of the finest TV series ever.


Maj John Howard was not very happy with the Pegasus Bridge book and even before Ambrose had it published.He requested that Ambrose make changes. Ambrose being the bloody know all would not make the changes and at a later date admitted he was wrong not to.






Whoever stands by a just cause and fights for the freedom and liberation of his land from the invaders, the settlers and the colonialists, cannot possibly be called terrorist."

— Yasser Arafat

Top
   
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 33 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next





It is currently Fri Feb 07, 2025 7:40 am


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 16 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  


It is currently Fri Feb 07, 2025 7:40 am
RLFANS Recent Posts
FORUM
LAST
POST
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
Recent
Season tickets
stpatricks
4
Recent
Transfer Talk V5
MjM
831
Recent
Catalans again
faxcar
15
Recent
Season launch
Victor
7
Recent
Film game
karetaker
7344
Recent
BORED The Band Name Game
karetaker
64556
Recent
Sheffield Challenge Cup A
NSW
24
Recent
Wakefield Trinity Heritage Podcast - Season 4
PopTart
9
Recent
London or Goole in cup
Trojan Horse
59
Recent
Goal kicker
rubber ducki
22
Recent
Rumours and signings v9
That Mon
29219
Recent
Salford
karetaker
162
Recent
RL Challenge Cup
rollin thund
27
Recent
Small squad numbers
ArthurClues
53
Recent
Game - Song Titles
BOSS HOG
41545
FORUM
LAST
VIEW
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
0s
Film game
karetaker
7344
5s
Season launch
Victor
7
11s
RL Challenge Cup
rollin thund
27
12s
Pre Season - 2025
B0NES
515
14s
ALL NEW 49ERS ERA LEEDS UTD THREAD
tad rhino
3036
15s
Challenge Cup - York Acorn
B0NES
39
16s
Game - Song Titles
BOSS HOG
41545
16s
Rumours and signings v9
That Mon
29219
22s
Super League
FIL
109
27s
London or Goole in cup
Trojan Horse
59
30s
BORED The Band Name Game
karetaker
64556
33s
We need injury update
Khlav Kalash
12
1m
Small squad numbers
ArthurClues
53
1m
HJ spruce-up
matt_wire
28
1m
Junior
Zig
33
FORUM
NEW
TOPICS
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
TODAY
Squad for the Cup game
The Speculat
3
TODAY
Last Man Standing - Match Prediction Competition
Jemmo
1
TODAY
We need injury update
Khlav Kalash
12
TODAY
Betfred Super League Season Set For Spectacular Start
RLFANS News
1
TODAY
Smoking vapes cheaper options
someonehasmy
1
TODAY
2025 Southstandercom Prediction Competition Week 1
Cokey
5
TODAY
Eagles v Wigan Parking
hawk-eye
1
TODAY
Squads - Leopards v Workington
LeythIg
3
TODAY
Sheffield Challenge Cup A
NSW
24
TODAY
LukeLittler stadium
sir adrian m
12
TODAY
French
Mark_P1973
4
TODAY
Can we compare
Big lads mat
11
TODAY
Goal kicker
rubber ducki
22
TODAY
A look behind the scenes at Warringtons preseason
ratticusfinc
10
TODAY
Cas H
Clickin'knee
25
TODAY
Fantasy Rugby League
Ashton Bears
1
NEWS ITEMS
VIEWS
Betfred Super League Season Se..
267
Thirteen Try York Knights Set ..
467
Comfortable Ash Handley Testim..
1164
Workington Town Set Up Leigh L..
950
Historic Goole Vikings Win Ove..
1054
Thatto Heath Hold On To Set Up..
1218
Army Beat The RAF In Challenge..
1187
Waterhead Warriors Golden Poin..
1273
Four From Rugby League Honoure..
1713
Leeds Rhinos Beat Wakefield Tr..
2514
Wigan Warriors crowned Team of..
2586
Ben Lam Leaves Dragons..
2350
New Roles for HULL KR...
2289
Jet2 has signed a major sponso..
2440
Thirkill and Hood complete Hul..
2604
RLFANS Match Centre
Matches on TV
Fri 7th Feb
CC2025
20:00
York-Hull KR
Sat 8th Feb
CC2025
12:00
Halifax-Catalans
Sun 9th Feb
CC2025
13:00
Bradford-Castleford
Thu 13th Feb
SL
20:00
Wigan-Leigh
Fri 14th Feb
SL
20:00
Hull KR-Castleford
SL
20:00
Catalans-Hull FC
Sat 15th Feb
SL
15:00
Leeds - Wakefield
SL
17:30
St.Helens-Salford
Sun 16th Feb
SL
15:00
Huddersfield-Warrington
Thu 20th Feb
SL
20:00
Wakefield - Hull KR
Fri 21st Feb
SL
20:00
Warrington-Catalans
SL
20:00
Hull FC-Wigan
Sat 22nd Feb
SL
15:00
Salford-Leeds
SL
20:00
Castleford-St.Helens
Sun 23rd Feb
SL
14:30
Leigh-Huddersfield
Fri 28th Feb
SL
20:00
Huddersfield-Hull FC
SL
20:00
Hull KR-Salford
SL
20:00
Leigh-Catalans
Sat 1st Mar
SL
14:30
Wakefield - St.Helens
SL
21:30
Wigan-Warrington
Sun 2nd Feb
CC2025 2 Keighley12-72York
1895 0 Midlands52-24Whitehaven
1895 0 Newcastle0-60Crusaders
Sat 1st Feb
1895 0 Rochdale64-12Cornwall
RLFANS Recent Posts
FORUM
LAST
POST
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
Recent
Season tickets
stpatricks
4
Recent
Transfer Talk V5
MjM
831
Recent
Catalans again
faxcar
15
Recent
Season launch
Victor
7
Recent
Film game
karetaker
7344
Recent
BORED The Band Name Game
karetaker
64556
Recent
Sheffield Challenge Cup A
NSW
24
Recent
Wakefield Trinity Heritage Podcast - Season 4
PopTart
9
Recent
London or Goole in cup
Trojan Horse
59
Recent
Goal kicker
rubber ducki
22
Recent
Rumours and signings v9
That Mon
29219
Recent
Salford
karetaker
162
Recent
RL Challenge Cup
rollin thund
27
Recent
Small squad numbers
ArthurClues
53
Recent
Game - Song Titles
BOSS HOG
41545
FORUM
LAST
VIEW
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
0s
Film game
karetaker
7344
5s
Season launch
Victor
7
11s
RL Challenge Cup
rollin thund
27
12s
Pre Season - 2025
B0NES
515
14s
ALL NEW 49ERS ERA LEEDS UTD THREAD
tad rhino
3036
15s
Challenge Cup - York Acorn
B0NES
39
16s
Game - Song Titles
BOSS HOG
41545
16s
Rumours and signings v9
That Mon
29219
22s
Super League
FIL
109
27s
London or Goole in cup
Trojan Horse
59
30s
BORED The Band Name Game
karetaker
64556
33s
We need injury update
Khlav Kalash
12
1m
Small squad numbers
ArthurClues
53
1m
HJ spruce-up
matt_wire
28
1m
Junior
Zig
33
FORUM
NEW
TOPICS
TOPIC
POSTER
POSTS
TODAY
Squad for the Cup game
The Speculat
3
TODAY
Last Man Standing - Match Prediction Competition
Jemmo
1
TODAY
We need injury update
Khlav Kalash
12
TODAY
Betfred Super League Season Set For Spectacular Start
RLFANS News
1
TODAY
Smoking vapes cheaper options
someonehasmy
1
TODAY
2025 Southstandercom Prediction Competition Week 1
Cokey
5
TODAY
Eagles v Wigan Parking
hawk-eye
1
TODAY
Squads - Leopards v Workington
LeythIg
3
TODAY
Sheffield Challenge Cup A
NSW
24
TODAY
LukeLittler stadium
sir adrian m
12
TODAY
French
Mark_P1973
4
TODAY
Can we compare
Big lads mat
11
TODAY
Goal kicker
rubber ducki
22
TODAY
A look behind the scenes at Warringtons preseason
ratticusfinc
10
TODAY
Cas H
Clickin'knee
25
TODAY
Fantasy Rugby League
Ashton Bears
1
NEWS ITEMS
VIEWS
Betfred Super League Season Se..
267
Thirteen Try York Knights Set ..
467
Comfortable Ash Handley Testim..
1164
Workington Town Set Up Leigh L..
950
Historic Goole Vikings Win Ove..
1054
Thatto Heath Hold On To Set Up..
1218
Army Beat The RAF In Challenge..
1187
Waterhead Warriors Golden Poin..
1273
Four From Rugby League Honoure..
1713
Leeds Rhinos Beat Wakefield Tr..
2514
Wigan Warriors crowned Team of..
2586
Ben Lam Leaves Dragons..
2350
New Roles for HULL KR...
2289
Jet2 has signed a major sponso..
2440
Thirkill and Hood complete Hul..
2604


Visit the RLFANS.COM SHOP
for more merchandise!












.