ST_CONROY wrote:RG3 is amazing. He can do anything, for me the most impressive thing is his accuracy.
However he has a significantly better team around him IMO. He has decent WR's and a good defence. Coupled with the ZBS where you can plug in any half decent RB.
Luck however has nothing except Reggie Wayne and a couple of rookie TE's. Plus a defence which has changed schemes. He has literally dragged that team into the playoffs and an excellent turn around from last season. He makes a few more mistakes, but that is because he has to take more chances given the lack of talent around him.
Ultimately they will be 2 of the best QB's in the league in time so it's splitting hairs.
Morris and Wilson shouldn't even be considered.
Again, I think the talent level thing is a fallacy.
The Redskins never had anyone compared to Reggie Wayne on their roster. Garcon was the Colts no. 2 WR and whilst he is a beast and I love him, he's was injured large parts of the season (his return, btw, was not coincidental with our upsurge in form). Fleener and Allen were 2nd and 3rd round draft picks. I'll agree Fred Davies is better but when he went down we had Logan Paulsen (an Undrafted Free Agent) and Niles Paul (a converted WR with 2 catches going into this year).
Yes, we have a better running game but that is not an argument against RGII, it's an argument FOR him. Firstly, he's contributed 800+ of those yards himself (another rookie record) and his presence in the read option has assisted Morris in many of the yards he has gained.
I agree that Luck has had the impact on the Colts you suggest he has but RGIII has had no less an impact in DC. he's turned around a locker room full of over paid malcontents into a team. He was named a captain at the bye week, remarkable for a rookie.
As you say, both will hopefully be 2 of the best Qbs in the league for some time to come and maybe it's a bit of homer bias in me but I think there has been some distance between Luck and RGIII this year, which is no slight on the year Luck has had, just that RGIII has been exceptional.