Joined: Mar 22 2009 Posts: 2397 Location: East Hull
Paea x2 next season. Byebye clinton.
Webster byebye. Replaced with a good player but who? Is quota reduced again next season? Hes surely on a fair whack so could be anyone at all that comes.
Really hope Galea is here next season but with reduced subs will he be able to play for long stints?
[quote="Adeybull"] so the panel took the same view as your excellent assessment.[/quote]
very red robin wrote:Is quota reduced again next season?
It wasn't reduced this one, their waiting for the exemptions to die out.
Tarquin Fuego wrote: I love Jamie and have done since he was 10 years old.
The Reason wrote:Hi Andy
The Rugby Football League are in the process of reviewing the video that you are referring to. We do not condone behaviour of this nature and have contacted the player’s employer, Hull F.C., who have confirmed that they are dealing with the incident under their club rules.
Joined: Jun 01 2007 Posts: 12672 Location: Leicestershire.
There's going to be little out there, so starting with retention. I wanted to do a 4 dimensional matrix for position, ability, attitude and quotas status but RLfans and normal Euclidean space are rubbish.
So club-trained qualified (because protectionism is the path to greater competivity, no really): For the sake of squad depth, we need to keep at least 2 of these, IMO. Murrell - the best cover we have or are likely to get for Green and Dobson and offers an option at 13. Enthusiastic, versatile... slow, but nobody is perfect. You know exactly what you're getting with him. I'd be happy to see him given 3 years which'd get him his testimonial, I think. Watts - In the ETS last year, loads of ability. On the other hand, when Willie Mason calls someone a larrikin it makes you nervous. Hope and fear in equal measure, for me. Probably got to gamble - the staff who work with him will know how far. Probably the biggest and hardest call. Lovegrove - Versatile, coming into his prime, started the season well. Keep.
Fed-trained - Hall - I think we could do with another back in the squad, so certainly wouldn't be looking to lose a talented, if slightly flaky, fed-trained one. Unless a couple of young players kick on to a surprising extent, I'd be surprised if we didn't try to extend his deal. Wheeldon - Under-rated IMO. But we do have a hypersufficiency of props, and he's ooc. Because Hull look to be short of props and (maybe) experienced club-trained players for 2013, he'd be a decent signing for them. If they look elsewhere (perhaps at Watts), and/or Clinton leaves and isn't replaced like-for-like, then he could stay. Otherwise, probably not, unless he finds another gear.
I'll do the non-fed and quota later.
'Thus I am tormented by my curiosity and humbled by my ignorance.' from History of an Old Bramin, The New York Mirror (A Weekly Journal Devoted to Literature and the Fine Arts), February 16th 1833.
Joined: Apr 06 2006 Posts: 1103 Location: The Heart of East Hull
I wouldn't be surprised to see hull go for wattsy following pearson's latest rallying call, they are targeting young established players from other clubs for next season now apparently and wattsy's old drinking partner westerman is there.
I'd like to see james green being given a long deal, I reckon with the right coaching he could well be the next taylor or cox to come through to being a first team regular
Joined: Jun 01 2007 Posts: 12672 Location: Leicestershire.
In terms of the quota, not much to be gained by Webster and Galea going, whereas McDonnell and Clinton departing would free up non-fed spots. Galea being injured is unfortunate for him, but at least it is obvious that we miss him. As with the rest, wait and see to an extent - but if we're looking to bring new players in, something has to give.
'Thus I am tormented by my curiosity and humbled by my ignorance.' from History of an Old Bramin, The New York Mirror (A Weekly Journal Devoted to Literature and the Fine Arts), February 16th 1833.
Joined: Mar 10 2011 Posts: 1508 Location: Bumblescum, AL
Mild Rover wrote:There's going to be little out there, so starting with retention. I wanted to do a 4 dimensional matrix for position, ability, attitude and quotas status but RLfans and normal Euclidean space are rubbish.
So club-trained qualified (because protectionism is the path to greater competivity, no really): For the sake of squad depth, we need to keep at least 2 of these, IMO. Murrell - the best cover we have or are likely to get for Green and Dobson and offers an option at 13. Enthusiastic, versatile... slow, but nobody is perfect. You know exactly what you're getting with him. I'd be happy to see him given 3 years which'd get him his testimonial, I think. Watts - In the ETS last year, loads of ability. On the other hand, when Willie Mason calls someone a larrikin it makes you nervous. Hope and fear in equal measure, for me. Probably got to gamble - the staff who work with him will know how far. Probably the biggest and hardest call. Lovegrove - Versatile, coming into his prime, started the season well. Keep.
Fed-trained - Hall - I think we could do with another back in the squad, so certainly wouldn't be looking to lose a talented, if slightly flaky, fed-trained one. Unless a couple of young players kick on to a surprising extent, I'd be surprised if we didn't try to extend his deal. Wheeldon - Under-rated IMO. But we do have a hypersufficiency of props, and he's ooc. Because Hull look to be short of props and (maybe) experienced club-trained players for 2013, he'd be a decent signing for them. If they look elsewhere (perhaps at Watts), and/or Clinton leaves and isn't replaced like-for-like, then he could stay. Otherwise, probably not, unless he finds another gear.
I'll do the non-fed and quota later.
C'mon über mod, your post is scruffy and was a perfect time to adopt DD's favourite list format(s). I've gone with the tried and tested bulleted format
From the list of ooc players you provided.
McDonnell - He's improving, but a 1yr deal, suggests we're open to other options next season
Hall - new deal, no brainer
Webster, in terms of the quota – you’re right, we may as well offer him a new deal – reduced terms, if he’s on particularly high wage.
Wheeldon - I’d like to see us keep him, he’s often been on the fringes and apparently surplus for a while. He’s chose to stay here, I like that loyalty. He doesn’t let us down.
Clinton – Suppose it depends on if he wants to stay or not, but you’d imagine he’s returning home. So
Watts – hasn’t been on top form, but he’s young and obviously highly rated. Keep if possible
Murrell – unless we could find another larker who fits in like he does, then it’s another no brainer, keep.
Lovegrove – keep.
Galea – If he’s got another season in him then, keep. If not then let’s put a nice contract Manu’s way.
We need to look at other back-up wing options. Latus isn't the answer.
Joined: Mar 10 2011 Posts: 1508 Location: Bumblescum, AL
barham red wrote:McDonnell improving, must have missed that one, looks a very average signing ATM.
Based on early season games, yes he's had solid-ish games vs Widnes(I know) and Bradford. Hell, he even made a tackle vs Bradford. So from fumbling and given away needless goal line drop outs and not making any tackles - he's improving.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 58 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum