Sorry but IMO J hodgson's best roles for Hull KR are away from hooker, for me he is better suited to 13.

Withers would be my hooker of choice

Well done for proving that you know sweet Edit-AS all about RL.

Everyone is entitled to an opinion on players, I don't agree with Dum-Dum on this but there will be another player that he rates that you don't.


I like Withers and his ability to slot in at 7 is a bonus

Josh looks like he is going to prove Mr Gekko (remember him) right though. He's been up there with Mika as our best player.

Not seen enough of Carlisle

Withers was always to good for crusaders am sure keal will get his chance soon I think it's just cos I ant really seen him play am sure ur right bout him

Give over, what makes Withers so good?

We'd not have signed him hadn't the RFL laxed the rules for Crusaders players.

You would think the Crusaders were a team of superstars the way people are carrying on, they weren't and Withers is no exception.

Just me that thinks all 3 hookers weve got are average at best then?

Withers was great in Aus but is average over here and isn't getting younger, our two lads are just that, lads, and we've all seen Josh progress, it's anyone's guess how good he'll get. Carlile on the other hand was outstanding before his troubles and given a bit of time and trust he'll be a game breaker.

another one who knows nothing

withers was the reason dobson didnt make it in austrailia and did you watch the saints game withers ran the show until he was injured

He was allowed the time and space by our big nice bloke forwards, as proven by the fact that we weren't outplayed when he went off.