Joined: Dec 19 2007 Posts: 237 Location: Underground
Tricky2309 wrote:If we dont retain Tongia who other than Cockayne will be able to play full back? Its a specialised position and for me we need to have another option in case injury strikes.
Tongia has a 12 month contract, we are trying to get Sam off quota so we can sign him as were already full on overseas quota
gowerthegroap wrote:How is Sam still on quota?! He has been here since 2004?
and in the Wakefield Express this very morn, it says we are looking at someone from the NRL... Tongia per chance?!... expert journalism!!
Classed as federation trained but on quota as he has yet to apply for British resedency. If he does get himself a british passport then he'll come off the quota.
Joined: Oct 26 2006 Posts: 13793 Location: No bowl, stick, STICK!
mole rat wrote:Tongia has a 12 month contract, we are trying to get Sam off quota so we can sign him as were already full on overseas quota
I’d rather the club (all clubs) just stopped using these loopholes and stuck to the limit of five overseas players. It’s not as if the overseas players brought in are mind-blowingly good. Although I like Obst as a player, there is simply no need for him if Smith is successful with his visa application.
Joined: Aug 18 2005 Posts: 27039 Location: In the fridge
Khlav Kalash wrote:I’d rather the club (all clubs) just stopped using these loopholes and stuck to the limit of five overseas players. It’s not as if the overseas players brought in are mind-blowingly good. Although I like Obst as a player, there is simply no need for him if Smith is successful with his visa application.
We'll end up with full quota and then a few that are off quota, no wonder RL is up the spout in this country.
No doubt steading the ship will be a good enough excuse for helping to destroy RL.
Joined: Oct 26 2006 Posts: 13793 Location: No bowl, stick, STICK!
BIGAL1 wrote:We'll end up with full quota and then a few that are off quota, no wonder RL is up the spout in this country.
No doubt steading the ship will be a good enough excuse for helping to destroy RL.
As it stands, John, Smith, Morrison or Southern, Collis or Mellars and Lauititti would be more than enough to compliment the squad with the mix of British/French players here also. The additional Tony, the other two either/or’s and potentially Obst will just be taking the space up of home recruits whilst not offering massively more on the pitch.
Khlav Kalash wrote:As it stands, John, Smith, Morrison or Southern, Collis or Mellars and Lauititti would be more than enough to compliment the squad with the mix of British/French players here also. The additional Tony, the other two either/or’s and potentially Obst will just be taking the space up of home recruits whilst not offering massively more on the pitch.
Exactly, and the sad thing is we had a chance to get away from this sort of signing at the early part of next year. It should have been a watershead. This wonder with imports and packing them in has to change, we need a whole culture change and the first stage is to stop bringing over journeymen, crocks, has beens and never will be's.
And before anybody starts, I don't care if Rangi Chase plays for England, I don't care if Hull KR do it, I'm not bothered that England RU and Cricket bend the rules - this is my club and my game and I think its wrong.
Is our season going to be much worse if we had Mathers instead of Tony or Tongia? Would we finish much lower down the league if we had Moore in the halfs instead of john or smith? We've got rid of some poor imports in hicky, Hendo, Korki and Smith (hopefully Semi too) and we replace them, most likely, more of the same.
Its lazy and I am sick of us taking the easy option, if Obst comes back (as good as he was for us) it speaks volumes about us and our contribution to the game. 6 months ago the board was flooded with posters crowing about how good the local league set up is, how its a hot bed of RL round here and how Wakefield have produced huge amounts of players and how much of a travesty it would have been if Crusaders had been given the gig instead of us.
We had the excuse of no dosh and relegation hanging over us when Ted was in charge, so the young 'uns went elsewhere. I wonder what Glover and Agar's excuse is?
Shame, cos we appear to be making decent strides in plenty of other areas.
We put this festival on you ba****ds With whole lotta love We worked for one year for you pigs And you wanna break our walls down And you wanna destroy Well you go to hell
Tommy Duckfingers wrote:And before anybody starts, I don't care if Rangi Chase plays for England, I don't care if Hull KR do it, I'm not bothered that England RU and Cricket bend the rules - this is my club and my game and I think its wrong.
I agree with the majority of your post, but I suppose the Chase example is pertinent; if the people running the game at the very top level are prepared to cynically exploit the loopholes that currently exist to crowbar a player like Chase into the national side, it's hardly a surprise that SL clubs will do the same thing. Last season, we even had the unedifying spectacle of the RFL colluding with HKR to cheat Willy Mason into their squad - a pretty low point for RL.
Either way it needs sorting, for all the reasons you've highlighted.
Tommy Duckfingers wrote:Exactly, and the sad thing is we had a chance to get away from this sort of signing at the early part of next year. It should have been a watershead. This wonder with imports and packing them in has to change, we need a whole culture change and the first stage is to stop bringing over journeymen, crocks, has beens and never will be's.
And before anybody starts, I don't care if Rangi Chase plays for England, I don't care if Hull KR do it, I'm not bothered that England RU and Cricket bend the rules - this is my club and my game and I think its wrong.
Is our season going to be much worse if we had Mathers instead of Tony or Tongia? Would we finish much lower down the league if we had Moore in the halfs instead of john or smith? We've got rid of some poor imports in hicky, Hendo, Korki and Smith (hopefully Semi too) and we replace them, most likely, more of the same.
Its lazy and I am sick of us taking the easy option, if Obst comes back (as good as he was for us) it speaks volumes about us and our contribution to the game. 6 months ago the board was flooded with posters crowing about how good the local league set up is, how its a hot bed of RL round here and how Wakefield have produced huge amounts of players and how much of a travesty it would have been if Crusaders had been given the gig instead of us.
We had the excuse of no dosh and relegation hanging over us when Ted was in charge, so the young 'uns went elsewhere. I wonder what Glover and Agar's excuse is?
Shame, cos we appear to be making decent strides in plenty of other areas.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 50 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum