Agreed there. I'm actually surprised the RFL have stuck with it this long given the attendances it's been getting (I've not been to them all, I didn't go to Scotland). I loved the weekends away in Cardiff.

As long as it makes any money they'll stick with it, if it only made the RFL £50k that's 50k more than not staging it.

That's a fair point.

I've been to all of them and I think moving to Scotland was a mistake. I'm still convinced that had they stayed at Cardiff it would have grown. I was actually surprised that we managed to get 60,000 last year for the 2 days as it was far too early in the year for a 7 game tournament and still very cold even with the roof on.
Manchester on the second May BH weekend could easily be something close to a sellout. I will certainly be going if it is confirmed.

I remember driving along the M4 through the fog to get to Cardiff, but i will say i actually prefer watching games when it's between 4-10 degrees, it just feels 'atmospheric', or probably just nostalgia from being a kid.

I loved the timing

I felt quite cold on both days at Cardiff and if it was on in February 2012 I question whether I would go again, however it wasn't half as cold as being in the 'Gulag' that is Murrayfield in 2010. Murrayfield was a mistake, I certainly wouldn't go again (the DJ throwing a bottle at us on the Saturday night didn't help).

I like the idea of it, but it just puts a slant on the league when you then have teams playing uneven fixtures.

How they can justify (for example) Wire (a title contender) playing Widnes, and two other top sides in Saints + Wigan playing each other?

I'd do something like what they are doing at Wembley with the double header international game, but throw in the final of 7's tournament or some other club based tournaments to appeal to the people who aren't bothered about international games.

I'm all for it being in Manchester though if it's going to happen, cost of going to Wales (and staying overnight) has put me off in the past.

If it is the same concept as last year and at the Millennium, then the season may be starting a week earlier as already being talked about. According to the 'Events' section of the Millennium Stadium website, Wales play Scotland in an international union match on Sun Feb 12th 2012 which is the weekend the Magic weekend took place last year!

whereever it is i wont be going if its end of may as im away but manchester would be ideal and makes sence

And the cheapest ticket is £70 !!