CHURCHILL wrote:Saints can be beaten with a decent kicking game, strong defence and most important of all composure. A little bit of luck also if it can be arranged.
Agree, saints are a good cup team that will go into the game knowing they will win which is a massive advantage to them, we need that mentality to win. Anyone wanting morgan to go is deluded, getting noble in is pure madness, he is the most negative boring coach ever, wigan needed to get rid to progress why would he be good enough for us. Fickle fans need to get a grip JM has at least e years grace before we call for him.
Joined: Jul 15 2005 Posts: 29811 Location: West Yorkshire
SirStan wrote::NAUGHTY: Don't go dragging me into this Mrs. Where did we go wrong?
You didn't shut down Tomkins, cockle. The scoreline though was very misleading and Rovers deserved a smaller losing margin. What do you think of Hodgson? I don't see much of him, but he seems to be a bit of a scapegoat along with Netherton and was a bit poor tonight. Also he shoved Horne in the back unnecessarily when Briscoe scored the final try at the KC derby, so he's on my naughty step.
Joined: Jan 19 2006 Posts: 1338 Location: Hibbing, Minnesota.
Hutchie wrote:1) VR was spot on, on all decisions 2) Flat pass was OK 3) You'll be above us next week 4) Its sad to see the decline of Shaun Briscoe 5) Murell got put on his 'arris more times than Frank Bruno
Well you got no. 4 right anyway. Think the man has been too brave for his own good in the past, too many blows to the head and face he doesn't put his body on the line quite like he did which was his main asset.
Don't say I blame him there's a lot of life after a Rugby League career. When he retires maybe he will get his nose fixed, there's not a lot of point while he's still playing Rugby League!
Mrs Barista wrote:You didn't shut down Tomkins, cockle. The scoreline though was very misleading and Rovers deserved a smaller losing margin. What do you think of Hodgson? I don't see much of him, but he seems to be a bit of a scapegoat along with Netherton and was a bit poor tonight. Also he shoved Horne in the back unnecessarily when Briscoe scored the final try at the KC derby, so he's on my naughty step.
I know you weren't asking me as such but netherton is a scapegoat to a certain extent although he's not the most exciting player in the world where as hodgson just isn't good enough and the big difference between the two is that hodgson plays in a position that is far too important to have a player in who isnt good enough. I Realise this answer may give you reason to feel smug (we got hodgson from you) but I'm not bothered about that just interested in proper debate about the game, players etc.
Joined: Aug 27 2008 Posts: 2255 Location: Always to the left!
stew wrote::KATA: I know you weren't asking me as such but netherton is a scapegoat to a certain extent although he's not the most exciting player in the world where as hodgson just isn't good enough and the big difference between the two is that hodgson plays in a position that is far too important to have a player in who isnt good enough. I Realise this answer may give you reason to feel smug (we got hodgson from you) but I'm not bothered about that just interested in proper debate about the game, players etc.
I must admit, of all of the players that you've had from us, i thought Hodgson would be the biggest miss on our part and would haunt us the most. Particularly after Berro went.
In hindsight, and it's in no way trying to sound smug, he is simply not good enough for this level yet.. He cost you the derby game at Craven Park (with the knock on IIRC) and on the TV games i've seen i can't recall him having a good game. For a hooker this is unacceptable!!
EL CAMO wrote:The majority of fans at Craven Park...are idiots who know nothing about the game.
Joined: Jan 19 2006 Posts: 1338 Location: Hibbing, Minnesota.
Mrs Barista wrote:You didn't shut down Tomkins, cockle. The scoreline though was very misleading and Rovers deserved a smaller losing margin. What do you think of Hodgson? I don't see much of him, but he seems to be a bit of a scapegoat along with Netherton and was a bit poor tonight. Also he shoved Horne in the back unnecessarily when Briscoe scored the final try at the KC derby, so he's on my naughty step.
Yes you can keep your spear tackles and chicken wings and your Yeaman assaults to the head. It's the shove in the back that rugby league needs to clamp down on.
FC Wembley 08 wrote:I must admit, of all of the players that you've had from us, i thought Hodgson would be the biggest miss on our part and would haunt us the most. Particularly after Berro went.
In hindsight, and it's in no way trying to sound smug, he is simply not good enough for this level yet.. He cost you the derby game at Craven Park (with the knock on IIRC) and on the TV games i've seen i can't recall him having a good game. For a hooker this is unacceptable!!
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 43 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
