Moa is an excellent impact forward, one that I feel would do well in the NRL, I hop Hull sign him up on a loan term deal.
Tickles a very good consistent player.
Both him, Moa and Houghton would get into Rovers 17.
That made me chuckle.
"They supercede individuals, they supercede the team and they supercede the club. Our club is a traditional, working class club and the supporters are loyal and passionate and to see them go away happy really makes my day." Craig Sandercock.
Moa is an excellent impact forward, one that I feel would do well in the NRL, I hop Hull sign him up on a loan term deal.
Tickles a very good consistent player.
Both him, Moa and Houghton would get into Rovers 17.
I'd take Houghton in a heart beat. I can see what Moa does for your team, and he could make an impact at Rovers, although I still think he lacks fitness and manoeverability. Tickle wouldn't get into Rovers side, we have far better back row forwards than him, even if big Willie fails to appear.
Moa is an excellent impact forward, one that I feel would do well in the NRL, I hop Hull sign him up on a loan term deal.
Tickles a very good consistent player.
Both him, Moa and Houghton would get into Rovers 17.
I'd take Houghton in a heart beat. I can see what Moa does for your team, and he could make an impact at Rovers, although I still think he lacks fitness and manoeverability. Tickle wouldn't get into Rovers side, we have far better back row forwards than him, even if big Willie fails to appear.
Moa is an excellent impact forward, one that I feel would do well in the NRL, I hop Hull sign him up on a loan term deal.
Tickles a very good consistent player.
Both him, Moa and Houghton would get into Rovers 17.
You my friend are as blinkered as they come; Tickle is average at best now and cant see whos place he would take in the HKR line up.
Moa is not "excellent" imo - feka was an excellent impact prop; again cant see whos place he would take as we play a different style of rugby to you, as you can see Wheeldon doesnt make the yards Moa does but certainly makes a better defensive player.
Fisher for Houghton would be the only 1 i would take as hes younger, more skillful and going to be around alot longer (but fish has good experience) imo this is Fishers last year with us anyway.
Moa is an excellent impact forward, one that I feel would do well in the NRL, I hop Hull sign him up on a loan term deal.
Tickles a very good consistent player.
Both him, Moa and Houghton would get into Rovers 17.
You my friend are as blinkered as they come; Tickle is average at best now and cant see whos place he would take in the HKR line up.
Moa is not "excellent" imo - feka was an excellent impact prop; again cant see whos place he would take as we play a different style of rugby to you, as you can see Wheeldon doesnt make the yards Moa does but certainly makes a better defensive player.
Fisher for Houghton would be the only 1 i would take as hes younger, more skillful and going to be around alot longer (but fish has good experience) imo this is Fishers last year with us anyway.
[quote="Adeybull"] so the panel took the same view as your excellent assessment.[/quote]
SirStan wrote:I'd take Houghton in a heart beat. I can see what Moa does for your team, and he could make an impact at Rovers, although I still think he lacks fitness and manoeverability. Tickle wouldn't get into Rovers side, we have far better back row forwards than him, even if big Willie fails to appear.
Dropped a lot of timber in pre-season, and his fitness is 110% better...also his off load is becoming a fantastic part of his game.
very red robin wrote:You my friend are as blinkered as they come; Tickle is average at best now and cant see whos place he would take in the HKR line up.
Moa is not "excellent" imo - feka was an excellent impact prop; again cant see whos place he would take as we play a different style of rugby to you, as you can see Wheeldon doesnt make the yards Moa does but certainly makes a better defensive player.
Fisher for Houghton would be the only 1 i would take as hes younger, more skillful and going to be around alot longer (but fish has good experience) imo this is Fishers last year with us anyway.
Joined: Sep 18 2005 Posts: 8742 Location: 2017 City of Culture
berrigans bitch wrote:Dropped a lot of timber in pre-season, and his fitness is 110% better...also his off load is becoming a fantastic part of his game.
Please explain the concept of 110% fitness improvement.
Joined: Mar 22 2009 Posts: 2397 Location: East Hull
Whiting Vs Shaun Briscoe Sharp Vs Peter Fox Manu Vs Kris Welham Yeaman Vs Jake Webster Briscoe Vs Liam Colbon Turner Vs Blake Green Long Vs Michael Dobson O’Meley Vs Joel Clinton Houghton Vs Ben Fisher Lauaki Vs Mick Vella Westerman Vs Clint Newton Tickle Vs Ben Galea Fitzgibbon Vs Scott Murrell
Moa Vs Scott Wheeldon Cunningham Vs Josh Hodgson Washbrook Vs Liam Watts Lyne Vs Ben Cockayne
Would anyone make any changes to that?
[quote="Adeybull"] so the panel took the same view as your excellent assessment.[/quote]
Joined: Sep 18 2005 Posts: 8742 Location: 2017 City of Culture
berrigans bitch wrote:Danny Tickle average
He's the very definition of average when looking at the total pool of 2nd Row talent in SL. Only his goalkicking sets him aside, and we already have a statistically better kicker in our team.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 90 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
