Looked great in a great saints team a few years back but can't see many saints fans who have a good word for him now.

Hope he does sign for you next year

If he came at the right price then it wouldnt be too bad of a deal, but we arent short of players in the back row

Been poor for two season now, i'd stay clear.

I think Saints are a lot stronger then people are giving them credit for.

Theyve signed young english players in Shenton & LMS, have 2 international standard hookers in Roby & Moore. I also think we'll see a strong 2nd season from Soliola who spent a lot of time injured this year.

I think they will be there or there abouts next season to win the Grand Final.

not forgetting josh perry from manly sea eagles as well.

Plus Josh Perry and they have some very good youngsters who are maturing well too. They will have a good pack and good backs, I fancy Roby to really step up at hooker.

whose coming in for Gidley though?

id welcome Wilkin back, hes still good enough to make the Saints team week in week out, and there a little bit better than us arent they

Me too, if anything getting rid of the old heads could even make them stronger.

[quote="tonylRobin"]whose coming in for Gidley though?


michael shenton.

The Hull fans saying he is crap, thats as good a reason as any for us to sign him he must be doing something right