Who would be your choice then? I think Bentham's the best one ATM.

Richard Silverwood.

Without a doubt the BEST ref in SL.

Always wondered who Zod really was.

Just thought i'd join in

Do you agree though??

No, too whistle-happy for me, particularly in a derby where the only involvement should be to stop the 2 sides killing each other . Bentham's my favourite, although I would have been happy with Allibert for this fixture on the basis he's easily swayed by the home crowd.

Disagree. They should cover all the internal bases but getting involved with trying to influence referees is something that should be cut out.

He should have more faith in his players.

Maybe his faith in his players isn't the problem.

Least worst. That doesn't scan does it. Back to Mild Rover Grammar Classes for me.

And that says a lot, none of them really seem to understand the game and let it flow, I really dislike our habit of following the Australasian game but getting enough officials up to standard and having two per game seems to have really worked over there.

I have to say, since Richie Silver Shorts started wearing a looser cut, his game seems to have improved.

Interesting, or maybe I'm just Goose Gonad Obsessed today.

Seriously - referee totty-o-meter? Right up my street.

Thaler - undisputed winner (if a bit young)
Smith - Silver fox - like it, more my age
Childs - nice head of hair, but high maintenance
Silverwood - looks like an accountant, i.e. dullard
Ganson - bit of a swagger, but too much edge (it's a fine line)
Bentham - too bald and sensible
Alibert - too skinny, not enough edge