barham red wrote:Go on then name them?
Cooke wasn;t captain of the CC team or the GF team. So to say he led them is a bit misleading. Working on your logic Ryan Bailey is a better prop than James Graham as he's won the GF more.
In my team I'd rather have;
Long, Sinfield, Chase, Tomkins, Eastmond and Briers than him.
I'm not saying that the fact he's played in the GF and CC more than Dobson is absolute proof however it's clear that the HB is a vital cog in a team - perhaps the single most vital (see us and Bradford in recent years for proof). Cooke has being a very important player for a team who have won the CC final and got to a grand final and has proven he can be a top player in a top team whereas Dobson hasn't.