............................Hall............Tansey
Appearances..........18................22
Tries....................09................07
Goals...................03................00
Tackles................116................81
Missed tackles........18................24
Errors...................14................36
Penalties................02................11
Meters...................848...............1902

Yeh, i can see where your coming from!

back to topic. imo craig hall with a bit of confidence has the ability with ball in hand to score something out of nothing. not the strongest in defence tho. however without confidence, his knack for summat off the cuff and full length of the pitch tries is reduced to zero, and basic errors creep in and is a waste of time.
confidence players are always a gamble which can go either way

[quote="GraftonRed"]............................Hall............Tansey
Appearances..........18................22
Tries....................09................07
Goals...................03................00
Tackles................116................81
Missed tackles........18................24
Errors...................14................36
Penalties................02................11
Meters...................848...............1902

Yeh, i can see where your coming from![/quote]

You can't say that about the future England full back

Dont
Its like being cruel to a Puppy

I hope not.
I would take a half fit (majority of the time) Karl Pryce anyday over Hall.

i remember when kris welham was well known for his poor tackling maybe Agar just hasn't spent the time with hall to make him into a better defence player, i think Morgan would see it as a challenge and to also stick two fingers up to the dullers, i would welcome Craig Hall

Stats don't tell the full picture especially when you only post half of them avaliable. How does Tansey's try assists, tackle busts and attacking kicks stack up to Hall's? If you think Craig Hall's contribution to Hull FC is greater than Jordan Tansey's then you need to watch a hell of a lot more of our games.

gingerspice wrote:i remember when kris welham was well known for his poor tackling maybe Agar just hasn't spent the time with hall to make him into a better defence player, i think Morgan would see it as a challenge and to also stick two fingers up to the dullers, i would welcome Craig Hall With 4 players in the top 11 for missed tackles it hardly seems Morgan is the expert in making players into top defenders... http://superleague.co.uk/statistics_pla ... 10&hp2=263

gingerspice wrote:i remember when kris welham was well known for his poor tackling maybe Agar just hasn't spent the time with hall to make him into a better defence player, i think Morgan would see it as a challenge and to also stick two fingers up to the dullers, i would welcome Craig Hall With 4 players in the top 11 for missed tackles it hardly seems Morgan is the expert in making players into top defenders... http://superleague.co.uk/statistics_pla ... 10&hp2=263

Wingers are usually receiving assists rather than supplying them.

Surely this can only be measured by how many times you've been tackled, IE, if he's been tackled 117 times then it's bad, if only 17 times then it's good.

It's usually a wingers duty to recieve the ball and run the ball over the line, or to run onto "an attacking Kick" to score..

Thats why i didn't bother with those stats.

Oh and

No thanks, i like to be entertained......... mind you, Friday..........

[quote="GraftonRed"]............................Hall............Tansey
Appearances..........18................22
Tries....................09................07
Goals...................03................00
Tackles................116................81
Missed tackles........18................24
Errors...................14................36
Penalties................02................11
Meters...................848...............1902

You do realise in Tansey's 22 appearances he played the full 80 and most of Craig Hall's have been cameos of half games? That said, Tansey's stats are shocking. Thank you for the pick-me-up!